Can You Have Sundowners Without Dementia?

Sundowning-like symptoms can occur without dementia, though dementia is by far the most common context in which they appear. The term “sundowning” or “sundown syndrome” describes a pattern of agitation, confusion, anxiety, or restlessness that emerges or worsens in the late afternoon and evening. While most research on sundowning focuses on Alzheimer’s disease and related dementias, the medical literature recognizes that these evening behavioral changes also show up in elderly patients without dementia, particularly during episodes of delirium triggered by infections, medications, or metabolic problems.

What Sundowning Actually Looks Like

Sundowning is not a formal medical diagnosis with strict criteria. It is a clinical term used broadly to describe a cluster of neuropsychiatric symptoms that appear or intensify as the day wears on. These symptoms include increased confusion, agitation, anxiety, restlessness, pacing, verbal outbursts, and sometimes aggression. The timing is the defining feature: someone who seems relatively calm and oriented during the morning becomes markedly more distressed as afternoon fades into evening.1PubMed Central. Sundown syndrome in persons with dementia: an update

Whether the phenomenon is truly tied to sunset itself remains debatable. Some researchers have questioned the direct link to the time of sunset, noting that the worsening does not always align neatly with diminishing daylight. Still, the weight of evidence points to a real time-dependent pattern: behavioral disturbances in people with Alzheimer’s and related dementias do tend to peak during late afternoon and early evening hours.2Frontiers in Neuroscience. Potential Pathways for Circadian Dysfunction and Sundowning-Related Behavioral Aggression in Alzheimer’s Disease and Related Dementias

Why Sundowning Is So Closely Tied to Dementia

The association between sundowning and dementia is strong for biological reasons. In Alzheimer’s disease, neurons in the part of the brain that acts as the body’s master clock degenerate over time. This brain region, located in the hypothalamus, coordinates your internal sense of day and night. When it deteriorates, the signals that keep sleep, wakefulness, body temperature, and hormone release synchronized with the 24-hour cycle start to fall apart. On top of that, the brain’s production of melatonin, the hormone that rises in darkness and promotes sleep, declines in dementia patients beyond the reduction already seen with normal aging.1PubMed Central. Sundown syndrome in persons with dementia: an update

Roughly one in five people living with Alzheimer’s disease is thought to experience sundowning.3Oxford Academic (Sleep). The role of actigraphy in detecting and characterizing the early phases of Alzheimer’s disease But that means the majority of people with Alzheimer’s do not sundown, which is itself an interesting point. The phenomenon is common in dementia but not inevitable, and its presence or absence depends on how much circadian disruption has occurred, what medications a person takes, what their environment looks like, and whether additional triggers are stacking on top of the underlying cognitive decline.

An early nursing-home study that looked at both demented and nondemented residents found that sundowners were more likely to have dementia, greater mental impairment, and more organic brain involvement than nonsundowners.4PubMed. Sundown syndrome in institutionalized elderly That finding has held up over the decades: dementia is the strongest single risk factor. But the study also observed both groups, which implies the question of sundowning in nondemented people was already on researchers’ radar.

Sundowning Without Dementia Does Happen

The clinical literature explicitly acknowledges that sundowning-type symptoms can appear in elderly patients who do not have dementia. One review described the phenomenon as a complex behavioral disorder occurring “in elderly patients with or without dementia at the time of sunset, at evening, or at night,” noting the tremendous costs it imposes on families and caregivers regardless of the underlying cause.5European Geriatric Medicine. Sundown syndrome and dementia

The most common non-dementia explanation is delirium. Delirium is a sudden change in mental state marked by confusion, disorientation, and fluctuating attention. Unlike dementia, which develops gradually over months or years, delirium comes on fast, often within hours or days, and it is usually triggered by something identifiable and treatable. Infections are the most frequent culprit, followed by dehydration, electrolyte imbalances, and medication side effects.6PubMed Central. Urinary Tract Infection Induced Delirium in Elderly Patients: A Systematic Review In hospital settings, additional precipitating factors include respiratory problems, pain, immobility, heavy sedation, and environments that disrupt normal sleep and sensory input.7PubMed Central. Prevention and Management of Delirium in the Intensive Care Unit

Delirium has a well-known tendency to worsen in the evening. Hospital nurses and ICU staff are thoroughly familiar with the pattern: a patient who was oriented and cooperative during morning rounds becomes confused and agitated after dark. This evening worsening of delirium can look virtually identical to the sundowning seen in dementia, even though the underlying cause is completely different. In the dementia version, the brain’s internal clock is broken by neurodegeneration. In the delirium version, an acute illness or metabolic crisis is temporarily scrambling the brain’s ability to process its environment, and the reduced sensory cues of nighttime make it worse.

The Role of Aging Itself

Even without dementia or delirium, normal aging makes the circadian system more fragile. Melatonin production naturally declines with age, and the body’s internal clock becomes less robust in its response to light and dark cues. These age-related changes in circadian rhythms are often linked to sleep disturbances and can sometimes produce mild sundowning-like restlessness or confusion in the evening.8Archives of Gerontology and Geriatrics. Melatonin for treatment of sundowning in elderly persons with dementia – a preliminary study

A hospitalized study of elderly patients found that among those who developed delirium compatible with sundown syndrome, the condition was associated with depressive symptoms and cognitive deficits but did not appear to be linked to infections, fever, number of medications, or length of hospital stay.9PubMed Central. Sundown syndrome and symptoms of anxiety and depression in hospitalized elderly That finding suggests that mood disorders like depression may independently contribute to the evening worsening pattern, especially in older adults who are already dealing with weakened circadian signaling. Depression disrupts sleep architecture, and poor sleep feeds back into worse evening functioning, creating a loop that can produce sundowning symptoms even when cognition is still relatively intact.

This is worth emphasizing because it changes the practical picture for families. If your older parent or grandparent starts getting confused or agitated in the evenings, dementia is not the only explanation. Untreated depression, a urinary tract infection, a medication that was recently changed, dehydration from not drinking enough during the day, or even the jarring unfamiliarity of a hospital room can all drive the same pattern. The key question is whether the evening confusion is new and sudden (which points toward delirium or an acute trigger) or has been building gradually over weeks and months alongside other memory and thinking problems (which points more toward dementia).

Environmental and Sensory Triggers

One factor that affects people with and without dementia is the environment itself. As daylight fades, visual cues become ambiguous. Shadows lengthen, contrast drops, and familiar spaces can look unfamiliar. For someone whose sensory processing is already compromised by age, poor eyesight, or hearing loss, this shift can be genuinely disorienting. In institutional settings like hospitals and nursing homes, the transition from a busy, well-lit daytime environment to a quieter, dimmer nighttime one often coincides with staff shift changes, reduced social interaction, and less structured activity, all of which can leave a vulnerable person feeling untethered.

The clinical recommendations that healthcare providers commonly make for managing sundowning reflect this understanding. Suggestions include ensuring a gradual transition from daylight to artificial lighting, minimizing unnecessary noise, sticking to stable daily routines, avoiding excessive sensory stimulation in the evening, discouraging long afternoon naps, and scheduling more demanding activities for earlier in the day.10Frontiers in Medicine. Sundowning in Dementia: Clinical Relevance, Pathophysiological Determinants, and Therapeutic Approaches These recommendations apply equally whether the person has dementia or is simply an older adult prone to evening confusion from other causes.

What Actually Helps

Treatment approaches for sundowning fall into two broad categories: addressing the underlying cause and managing the symptoms directly. When the cause is delirium from an infection or metabolic issue, fixing that trigger often resolves the evening confusion entirely. This is one of the most important practical differences between dementia-related sundowning and the non-dementia version: if the cause is treatable, the sundowning goes away.

For circadian-related symptoms, bright light therapy has gotten the most research attention. The logic is straightforward: if the internal clock is drifting, a strong light signal during the right part of the day might help re-anchor it. Controlled studies in older populations, including those with and without dementia, have found that a carefully timed light-dark pattern can improve sleep quality and consolidation.11PubMed Central. Light therapy and Alzheimer’s disease and related dementia: past, present, and future Some smaller studies have reported reduced restlessness and improved cooperation in patients receiving bright light therapy.12International Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry. Bright light therapy and melatonin in motor restless behaviour in dementia: a placebo-controlled study

The evidence is encouraging but not conclusive. A Cochrane review noted that there is insufficient high-quality evidence to fully endorse bright light therapy for improving cognition, sleep, or behavioral disturbances in dementia.10Frontiers in Medicine. Sundowning in Dementia: Clinical Relevance, Pathophysiological Determinants, and Therapeutic Approaches And a more recent systematic review looking specifically at sundowning behavior found no significant beneficial effect from bright light therapy across the studies analyzed.13Neurology Asia. A systematic review on the effect of light therapy in sundowning behavior of patients with dementia That said, the research base is thin, and no large randomized trial has specifically tested light therapy for sundowning as its primary outcome. Given that bright light exposure carries essentially zero risk, clinicians often recommend it anyway as part of a broader environmental strategy.

Beyond light therapy, melatonin supplementation, behavioral modifications, and in some cases pharmacological treatments such as antipsychotics or cholinesterase inhibitors have been used.1PubMed Central. Sundown syndrome in persons with dementia: an update Chronobiological approaches, essentially any non-drug strategy that works by resetting or stabilizing circadian rhythms through external timing cues, have shown promise for improving sleep and cognitive functioning in elderly people.14Behavioural Brain Research. Non-pharmacological treatment of sleep and wake disturbances in aging and Alzheimer’s disease: Chronobiological perspectives For someone without dementia whose sundowning is driven by age-related circadian weakening or a reversible trigger, these gentler interventions may be all that is needed.

When Evening Confusion Should Raise a Red Flag

One understandable worry for families is that evening confusion in an older relative could be the first visible sign of undiagnosed dementia. That concern is not unreasonable. Circadian disruption and fragmented sleep can precede the more obvious cognitive symptoms of Alzheimer’s disease by years. If you notice that an older family member is consistently more confused, anxious, or disoriented in the evenings and this pattern is gradually worsening over months, it is worth having a conversation with their doctor about cognitive screening.

But a single episode of evening confusion, or a new pattern that appears suddenly alongside an illness, a hospital stay, or a medication change, almost always has a simpler explanation. Delirium from a urinary tract infection is one of the most common reasons elderly people land in emergency rooms with acute confusion, and it can produce dramatic evening agitation that looks every bit as alarming as advanced dementia. Once the infection is treated, the confusion typically clears. The distinction matters enormously because delirium is a medical emergency that requires prompt treatment of the underlying cause, while dementia-related sundowning calls for a longer-term management strategy.

If you are trying to sort out what is going on with a specific person, the two most useful questions are about timeline and trajectory. Did the confusion come on suddenly over days, or has it been creeping in over many months? Is it getting steadily worse, or does it fluctuate wildly from one day to the next? Sudden onset with dramatic fluctuation strongly suggests delirium. Gradual onset with a slow downward trend suggests dementia. Both can produce sundowning, but the path forward looks very different.

Why the Science Remains Messy

Sundowning occupies an awkward space in medical research. It is widely recognized by clinicians and caregivers, yet it lacks a standardized definition, formal diagnostic criteria, or even a consensus on whether “sundowning” should be considered a syndrome in its own right or just a description of when certain symptoms happen to peak. This ambiguity makes it difficult to study rigorously. Researchers use different definitions, different observation windows, and different measures of severity, which is why the evidence base for treatments like light therapy remains inconclusive despite decades of interest.

The lack of formal recognition also means that sundowning in people without dementia is almost certainly under-studied. Most research is framed around Alzheimer’s disease because that is where the clinical burden is heaviest and the funding flows. An older adult without dementia who gets restless and confused every evening is more likely to have their symptoms attributed to anxiety, depression, insomnia, or just “getting old” than to be recognized as having a circadian-driven behavioral syndrome. That framing gap may lead to missed opportunities for relatively simple interventions like adjusting lighting, stabilizing routines, or treating an underlying infection that nobody thought to look for.

An Evolutionary Footnote on Evening Wakefulness

One intriguing piece of context comes from evolutionary biology. Research on modern hunter-gatherer groups has found that natural variation in sleep timing across different age groups means that someone in the group is almost always awake or in light sleep during the night, functioning as a kind of sentinel. Older adults, who tend to wake more frequently during the night and sleep more lightly, play a disproportionate role in this pattern.15PubMed Central. Chronotype variation drives night-time sentinel-like behaviour in hunter–gatherers The researchers proposed that age-related changes in sleep architecture, including the kind of nighttime wakefulness and restlessness that we now label as problematic, may be a legacy of natural selection rather than purely a sign of deterioration. None of this means sundowning is “normal” or harmless, but it does suggest that the aging brain’s tendency toward evening alertness and fragmented sleep has deeper evolutionary roots than a simple disease model might imply.

Corinne Walker

An Arizona State University nursing graduate, Corinne Walker, RN, directs a memory care floor at an assisted living facility. She trains nursing aides in calm, person-centered dementia care methods and oversees resident services. Before stepping into her administrative role, Walker worked as a bedside nurse across several long-term care units.