Why We Can’t Live on Mars: The Scientific Reasons

The idea of establishing a permanent human settlement on Mars captures the imagination, but the planet’s environment is profoundly inhospitable. Mars exists as a deeply hostile world, posing immediate and long-term threats to unprotected human biology. The challenges are not merely technological hurdles, but fundamental scientific barriers rooted in planetary physics and chemistry. Sustained human habitation requires resolving multiple lethal factors, including an atmosphere that instantly kills, a surface bathed in high-energy radiation, the physiological decay induced by low gravity, and a chemically toxic soil. These combined threats define Mars as fundamentally incompatible with human life without complete, continuous environmental isolation.

The Lethal Atmospheric Reality

The Martian atmosphere is functionally a vacuum, with a surface pressure less than one percent of Earth’s sea-level pressure. This extremely low pressure, averaging about 6 millibars, falls far below the “Armstrong limit,” the point where water boils at normal human body temperature. Unprotected exposure would immediately trigger ebullism, where the low pressure causes water in exposed bodily fluids, such as saliva, tears, and lung moisture, to vaporize.

This vaporization would cause severe swelling and tissue damage. The atmosphere is also overwhelmingly composed of carbon dioxide, accounting for over 95% of its volume. Even if the pressure were survivable, the lack of breathable oxygen means any human would experience rapid asphyxiation. Therefore, survival on the Martian surface depends entirely on pressurized habitats and sealed suits that replicate Earth’s atmospheric conditions.

Unshielded Radiation Hazard

Mars lacks a global, intrinsic magnetic field and has only a very thin atmosphere, failing to provide adequate shielding from space radiation. This exposes surface-dwelling organisms to two primary forms of high-energy particles: Galactic Cosmic Rays (GCRs) and Solar Particle Events (SPEs). GCRs are a constant, chronic background of highly energetic particles, including heavy charged nuclei (HZE ions), which penetrate deep into the body and cause complex damage to DNA and cells.

Exposure to this chronic radiation dramatically increases the lifetime risk of developing cancer and poses significant long-term threats to the central nervous system. The cumulative dose on the Martian surface is estimated to be approximately 0.65 milliSieverts per day. A mission lasting over two years could expose an astronaut to a total dose far exceeding current occupational limits. SPEs are unpredictable bursts of high-energy protons from the sun that can cause acute radiation sickness, including nausea, vomiting, and even death, if an astronaut is caught outside a heavily shielded shelter. Shielding is difficult because the thin Martian air is not dense enough to stop them, instead creating secondary, lower-energy radiation that penetrates habitats.

Physiological Impact of Low Gravity

Mars’s surface gravity is only 0.38g, or about 38% of Earth’s gravity, which is insufficient to prevent the severe physiological deconditioning seen in microgravity environments. The human musculoskeletal system relies on the mechanical loading of 1g to maintain bone density and muscle mass. In 0.38g, the body experiences significant bone resorption, where calcium is lost from the skeleton, leading to osteoporosis and an increased risk of kidney stones.

The cardiovascular system also suffers from reduced gravity, as the heart no longer needs to work against Earth’s pull to pump blood to the upper body. This leads to deconditioning of the heart muscle and a shift of body fluids toward the head, reducing overall blood volume. A significant long-term concern is Spaceflight Associated Neuro-ocular Syndrome (SANS), where chronic fluid shift can cause structural changes in the eye, including swelling of the optic nerve and vision impairment. The effects of low gravity on the growth and development of children, or on the reproductive process, remain completely unknown and represent a substantial biological risk.

Toxic Regolith and Resource Scarcity

The fine, dust-like Martian soil, known as regolith, is abrasive and chemically toxic due to the presence of perchlorate salts. These perchlorates are highly chlorinated compounds widely distributed across the planet at concentrations toxic to both humans and plants. Ingesting or inhaling these compounds can interfere with the human thyroid gland’s ability to absorb iodine, potentially leading to metabolic dysfunction.

This chemical contamination poses a direct barrier to developing local agriculture, known as in-situ resource utilization (ISRU). Experiments using Martian soil simulants show that perchlorates inhibit plant germination and growth. Future farming would require extensive and energy-intensive processing to neutralize the soil. Furthermore, extracting water or oxygen from the regolith means processing this toxic material, increasing the risk of contaminating the entire living environment with harmful chemicals and dust.