Why Is One Eye Blurry and the Other Isn’t?

When one eye’s vision suddenly becomes blurry while the other remains clear, it is known as monocular blur. This symptom occurs when the visual information gathered by each eye is significantly different, making it difficult for the brain to seamlessly merge the two images. A noticeable blur in a single eye indicates a problem within that eye’s structure, the optic nerve, or the visual pathways leading to the brain. Because the causes range widely, from a simple uncorrected refractive error to a serious medical event, any new or sudden monocular blur warrants professional examination.

Acute Conditions Requiring Emergency Care

The sudden onset of blurriness in one eye, particularly if accompanied by other symptoms, can signal a time-sensitive medical emergency that risks permanent vision loss. One such emergency is a retinal detachment, which happens when the light-sensitive layer at the back of the eye separates from its underlying support tissues. Patients often report an abrupt increase in floaters, flashes of light, or a curtain-like shadow moving across their field of vision, necessitating immediate surgical intervention.

Acute angle-closure glaucoma presents as a rapid spike in intraocular pressure, causing intense eye pain, redness, headache, nausea, and the perception of halos around lights. This occurs when the eye’s drainage angle becomes blocked, damaging the optic nerve within hours. Another serious cause is optic neuritis, an inflammation of the optic nerve that often causes rapid central vision loss and pain with eye movement.

Vascular events, sometimes called an “eye stroke,” pose a grave threat. A central retinal artery occlusion (CRAO) or central retinal vein occlusion (CRVO) involves a blockage in the blood supply to or from the retina. CRAO typically causes a sudden, painless loss of vision in one eye, while CRVO causes rapid blurring due to blood and fluid leakage. Sudden monocular vision loss, even if transient, can also be a symptom of a transient ischemic attack (TIA) or a stroke.

Common Ocular and Refractive Causes

Many instances of asymmetric blur are due to conditions that are less urgent but still require attention. A difference in the focusing power between the two eyes is known as anisometropia, where one eye may have a new or worsening refractive error like myopia, hyperopia, or astigmatism. This uneven focusing causes the light to land incorrectly on the retina in one eye, resulting in a blurry image the brain struggles to process alongside the clear image from the other eye.

Another frequent cause is dry eye syndrome, where the eye does not produce enough quality tears to maintain a smooth, clear corneal surface. The resulting tear film instability leads to fluctuating vision and blurriness, often feeling worse with prolonged viewing. Minor corneal issues, like a superficial scratch or a mild infection such as keratitis, can temporarily distort the cornea’s curvature, scattering light and causing blur in the affected eye.

Cataracts, the clouding of the eye’s lens, are a frequent cause of gradual blur that can progress unevenly between the eyes. If one lens clouds faster than the other, it creates a noticeable difference in visual clarity, often accompanied by increased glare sensitivity and faded color perception.

Systemic Health and Neurological Links

Conditions that begin outside the eye can also manifest as monocular blur, often reflecting chronic disease progression or transient neurological events. For individuals with diabetes, consistently high blood sugar levels can damage the tiny blood vessels in the retina, a process known as diabetic retinopathy. This damage can cause fluid to leak into the macula, leading to swelling and gradual blurring.

Similarly, uncontrolled high blood pressure (hypertension) can lead to hypertensive retinopathy, where chronic vessel damage causes changes in the retinal circulation that result in blur. Although these conditions affect both eyes, the progression of damage may be asymmetrical, causing one eye to become blurrier sooner than the other.

Certain neurological phenomena, such as a migraine with aura, can cause temporary monocular blur or visual distortions. The transient visual disturbances of a migraine aura can involve shimmering lights, zigzag lines, or a temporary blind spot in one eye that typically resolves within 30 minutes. Monocular blur can also be an early sign of a demyelinating disease, such as multiple sclerosis, where inflammation of the optic nerve causes vision loss.

The Clinical Evaluation and Next Steps

When experiencing new or unexplained monocular blur, the first step is to assess the urgency of the situation. If the blur is sudden, severe, or accompanied by intense pain, flashing lights, a curtain in the vision, or neurological signs like slurred speech or numbness, immediate emergency medical attention is necessary. For symptoms that are gradual, mild, or fluctuating without pain, a prompt appointment with an optometrist or ophthalmologist is the appropriate next step.

A professional eye examination begins with a thorough measurement of visual acuity, followed by refraction to determine if a simple change in prescription is the cause. The clinician uses a slit lamp biomicroscope to examine the anterior segment of the eye, including the cornea, iris, and lens, to detect surface issues, infections, or cataracts. Intraocular pressure is measured using tonometry to screen for glaucoma.

After administering dilation drops, the doctor performs a detailed fundus examination to view the back of the eye, including the retina, optic nerve, and macula. This allows for the direct assessment of conditions like retinal detachment, diabetic retinopathy, or optic nerve swelling. If a vascular or neurological cause is suspected, specialized tests such as Optical Coherence Tomography (OCT) or visual field testing may be ordered.

Treatment is always tailored to the underlying cause, ranging from corrective lenses for refractive errors to specialized eye drops or surgical procedures. For causes linked to systemic disease, management involves coordinated care with a primary care physician to control conditions like diabetes or hypertension. Professional care is the only reliable path to diagnosis and treatment.