Why Is It Impossible for an Element to Have an Atomic Number of 110.5?

The identity of every known substance is determined by the composition of its atoms. Each element possesses a unique set of characteristics, encoded in a single, defining numerical value known as the atomic number. This number acts as the ultimate identifier for any element.

Defining the Atomic Number (Z)

The atomic number, represented by the symbol Z, is defined by the precise count of protons residing within the atom’s nucleus. This number is an absolute characteristic; for example, every atom with Z=6 is carbon, and every atom with Z=92 is uranium. Changing this count instantly transforms the atom into a different element.

This proton count governs the arrangement of electrons surrounding the nucleus in a neutral atom. The electron configuration, particularly the electrons in the outermost shells, dictates how the atom will interact with others, determining its unique chemical properties. Consequently, the atomic number establishes the element’s placement and behavior within the periodic table.

The Discrete Nature of Subatomic Particles

The impossibility of an element having an atomic number like 110.5 stems from the discrete, indivisible nature of the proton itself. The atomic number is a simple tally of physical particles, and it is not possible to have half of a proton contributing to an atom’s identity. Protons exist as whole, distinct units.

A proton functions as the smallest unit of positive charge and mass that determines atomic identity. While physicists understand that a proton is composed of smaller particles called quarks, the proton itself remains the fundamental component of an atom’s nucleus that establishes its element type.

An atomic number of 110.5 would require the nucleus to contain 110 full protons plus an additional half of a proton. Since a proton cannot be physically divided and still function as the defining unit of atomic identity, the resulting count must always be a whole integer. Therefore, an atom can have 110 protons (Darmstadtium) or 111 protons (Roentgenium), but no element can exist between these whole numbers. The atomic number is always an integer because the definition of an element necessitates a whole number of protons.

Why Atomic Mass Appears Fractional

Confusion regarding fractional atomic numbers often arises from observing the atomic mass values listed on the periodic table, which are reported as decimals. Unlike the atomic number, which is a simple count, the atomic mass is a calculated value representing the weighted average of all naturally occurring isotopes of that element.

Isotopes are atoms of the same element that contain the same number of protons but a varying number of neutrons. For example, chlorine atoms exist naturally as a mixture of chlorine-35 and chlorine-37, differing by two neutrons. The atomic mass is calculated by factoring in the mass of each isotope and its relative abundance in nature.

The averaging process, which accounts for the differing masses and natural proportions of an element’s isotopes, results in the non-integer decimal value. This fractional atomic mass contrasts with the element’s atomic number, which, as a direct count of protons, must remain a fixed, whole integer.