Why Does My pH Keep Going Up? Common Causes

Maintaining stable water pH can be challenging, especially when it consistently rises. pH measures how acidic or alkaline water is, based on hydrogen ion concentration. A pH value of 7 is considered neutral; values below 7 indicate acidity, while values above 7 signify alkalinity. This upward drift in pH is a common observation for individuals managing various water environments, from aquariums to ponds and pools. Understanding the underlying chemical and biological processes is helpful for addressing this phenomenon.

Carbon Dioxide and Air Exchange

Carbon dioxide (CO2) plays a significant role in determining water chemistry. When CO2 dissolves in water, it reacts to form carbonic acid, a weak acid that releases hydrogen ions, thereby lowering the water’s pH. This equilibrium between dissolved CO2, carbonic acid, and other carbonate species directly influences the water’s acidity.

Water systems are constantly exchanging gases with the surrounding atmosphere. If CO2 is removed from the water, such as through surface agitation, aeration, or vigorous water movement, the chemical equilibrium shifts. This causes carbonic acid to break down, releasing fewer hydrogen ions and consequently leading to an increase in pH. This process, known as off-gassing, is where dissolved CO2 escapes into the air until equilibrium with atmospheric CO2 is reached.

Factors like water temperature, surface area exposed to air, and air movement across the water’s surface influence the rate of CO2 exchange. Warmer water holds less dissolved gas, so higher temperatures can accelerate CO2 off-gassing. Similarly, increased surface agitation, through fountains, waterfalls, or air stones, enhances the water’s contact with air, promoting rapid CO2 release and a subsequent pH rise.

Biological Activity in Water Systems

Living organisms within an aquatic environment can significantly influence pH through their metabolic activities. Aquatic plants and algae are primary examples, as they engage in photosynthesis during daylight hours. During photosynthesis, these organisms absorb carbon dioxide from the water to produce energy and oxygen. This consumption of dissolved CO2, an acidic component, directly reduces the amount of carbonic acid in the water.

As CO2 is removed from the water by photosynthetic organisms, the chemical balance shifts, leading to a measurable increase in pH. This effect is most pronounced during periods of strong light, resulting in a daily fluctuation where pH rises during the day and typically falls at night when photosynthesis ceases and organisms continue to respire, releasing CO2. This phenomenon is known as diurnal pH swing.

The extent of this pH increase depends on the density of photosynthetic organisms and the water’s buffering capacity. In systems with abundant plant life or algae, these diurnal swings can be quite noticeable. While photosynthesis is the main biological driver for pH increases, other biological processes might also contribute to the overall pH balance.

Minerals, Substrates, and Source Water

The dissolution of certain minerals from the materials used within a water system or present in the surrounding environment can significantly contribute to rising pH. Substrates, decorative elements, or even the construction materials of a pool or pond may contain carbonate-rich compounds, such as limestone or marble. When water comes into contact with these materials, they can slowly dissolve, releasing bicarbonates and carbonates into the water.

These released bicarbonates and carbonates act as natural buffers, meaning they have the capacity to neutralize acids and resist changes in pH. As these alkaline compounds accumulate, they increase the water’s alkalinity, which in turn drives the pH upward.

The characteristics of the initial source water also play a role. Source water with naturally high alkalinity and hardness contains a greater concentration of these buffering minerals. Such water naturally resists pH drops and tends to maintain a higher pH. Evaporation is another factor, as it removes pure water but leaves behind dissolved minerals. Over time, this concentration of minerals can lead to a gradual increase in the water’s overall alkalinity and consequently, its pH.