Why Do I Get Drunk Sometimes and Not Others?

The experience of intoxication can feel unpredictable, leading many to wonder why the same number of drinks sometimes results in a mild buzz and other times causes significant impairment. This inconsistency is governed by a complex interplay of immediate physiological factors, fixed biological differences, and the manner in which the alcohol is consumed. Understanding the mechanisms that control the rate of alcohol absorption, metabolism, and its effects on the central nervous system explains these differences.

The Role of Food, Hydration, and Sleep

Food intake is one of the most influential variables affecting how quickly a person becomes intoxicated. When alcohol is consumed on an empty stomach, it moves rapidly to the small intestine, where it is quickly absorbed into the bloodstream. Eating a meal, particularly one containing a mixture of protein, fat, and carbohydrates, slows down gastric emptying. This keeps the alcohol in the stomach longer, delaying its entry into the small intestine and allowing the liver more time to begin processing it. This results in a significantly lower peak Blood Alcohol Concentration (BAC) for the same amount consumed.

Hydration status also dramatically affects the level of intoxication. Alcohol acts as a diuretic, causing the body to excrete more fluid than it takes in, which leads to dehydration. Reduced water volume means the alcohol is dissolved in a smaller total volume of water, concentrating the alcohol. This potentially leads to a higher BAC and more intense side effects, such as headaches. Alternating alcoholic beverages with water can help mitigate this diuretic effect.

A lack of sleep or fatigue significantly lowers a person’s tolerance to alcohol’s effects. The cognitive impairment caused by sleep deprivation compounds the depressant effects of alcohol on the central nervous system. A tired person may feel substantially more impaired at a lower BAC than they would when well-rested. This occurs because the alcohol intensifies an already existing deficit in cognitive function.

Biological and Genetic Differences in Metabolism

Fixed biological differences contribute to a person’s baseline ability to process alcohol efficiently. The liver uses two primary enzymes to break down alcohol: Alcohol Dehydrogenase (ADH) and Aldehyde Dehydrogenase (ALDH). ADH converts ethanol into the toxic compound acetaldehyde, and ALDH then quickly converts acetaldehyde into harmless acetate.

Genetic variations in the genes that produce these enzymes can dramatically alter their activity. Some individuals possess variants of ADH that break down alcohol much faster. Others have an inactive or slow-acting variant of ALDH, which causes acetaldehyde to accumulate. This accumulation leads to unpleasant flushing, nausea, and rapid intoxication, a trait common in people of East Asian descent.

Body composition and sex also play a role in determining BAC. Alcohol is water-soluble, meaning it distributes throughout the body’s total water content. Men generally have a higher percentage of body water relative to fat and body weight than women, which allows the alcohol to be more diluted, resulting in a lower BAC for the same amount consumed. Women also typically have lower levels of the enzyme ADH in the stomach, meaning a greater proportion of alcohol reaches the bloodstream before first-pass metabolism occurs in the liver.

Influence of Consumption Speed and Acute Tolerance

The speed at which alcohol is consumed is perhaps the most controllable factor influencing intoxication levels. The liver can only metabolize alcohol at a relatively fixed rate, typically about one standard drink per hour. If a person drinks faster than this rate, the alcohol accumulates rapidly in the bloodstream, causing a sharp spike in BAC and a sudden onset of intoxication.

The type of drink consumed also influences the rate of absorption. Carbonated beverages, such as sparkling wine or mixed drinks made with soda, can speed up the absorption process. The carbon dioxide gas in these drinks increases pressure in the stomach, accelerating the movement of alcohol into the small intestine where absorption is faster.

A phenomenon known as acute tolerance, or the Mellanby effect, explains why a person might feel less drunk on the way down from peak intoxication than they did on the way up, even at the same BAC. This rapid, short-term adaptation means the central nervous system adjusts to the presence of alcohol during a single drinking session. This temporary feeling of sobriety can be deceiving, as actual physical and cognitive impairment may remain high.

Medications and Other External Substances

The presence of medications can significantly alter how the body processes alcohol, leading to unpredictable and sometimes harmful results. Many prescription and over-the-counter drugs are metabolized by the same liver enzyme systems, particularly the cytochrome P450 enzymes. When alcohol is present, it can compete with or inhibit the metabolism of these drugs, or the drugs can interfere with alcohol metabolism. This leads to a faster, more intense rise in BAC and prolonged effects.

Drugs that act as Central Nervous System (CNS) depressants also compound the effects of alcohol. Medications such as anxiety drugs (benzodiazepines), certain painkillers, or sleep aids slow down brain activity. When combined with alcohol, their depressant effects are dangerously magnified. This pharmacodynamic interaction increases the risk of extreme sedation, respiratory depression, falls, and memory lapses, even at moderate alcohol intake levels. It is always advisable to consult a healthcare provider or pharmacist regarding the safety of combining alcohol with any medication.