Why Do Eyes Change Colors? The Biological Reasons

Eye color is a distinct human characteristic. While typically considered a fixed trait, eye color can sometimes seem to shift or undergo actual biological alterations. These variations stem from a range of influences, encompassing both environmental interactions and internal bodily processes.

The Science Behind Eye Color

The color of a person’s eyes is primarily determined by the amount and distribution of melanin, a pigment produced by specialized cells called melanocytes, within the iris. The iris is the colored ring of muscle tissue surrounding the pupil, controlling how much light enters the eye. While virtually everyone has melanin in the back layer of their iris, the concentration and arrangement of this pigment in the iris’s front layers dictate the visible eye color.

Brown eyes, the most common eye color globally, result from a relatively high concentration of melanin in both layers of the iris, which absorbs most light. Conversely, blue eyes contain minimal melanin in the front layers of the iris. Their blue appearance is not due to blue pigment, but rather the result of Rayleigh scattering, a process where shorter blue wavelengths of light are scattered back from the turbid medium of the iris stroma, much like the scattering that makes the sky appear blue.

Green and hazel eyes represent intermediate levels of melanin. Green eyes have a low to moderate concentration of melanin, combined with a yellowish pigment and the blue scattering effect, producing their distinct hue. Hazel eyes possess more melanin than green eyes but less than brown, often appearing as a blend of brown, gold, or green, with light scattering also playing a role.

How Eyes Appear to Change Color

Eyes can often appear to change color due to various external factors, creating an optical effect rather than a true biological alteration of the iris pigment. Lighting conditions play a significant role in this perception, as the way light interacts with the melanin and structural elements of the iris can differ under various illuminations. For instance, natural sunlight can reveal different undertones and flecks in the iris compared to artificial indoor lighting, making eyes seem brighter, darker, or showing different shades.

The reflection of surrounding colors also influences how eye color is perceived. Colors from clothing, makeup, or a nearby wall can subtly reflect onto the eye’s surface, causing it to momentarily appear to shift its shade.

Changes in pupil size can further contribute to the illusion of altered eye color. When the pupil dilates in dim light or due to strong emotions, the dark center expands, potentially making the surrounding iris appear lighter or more intense by contrast. Conversely, a constricted pupil in bright light highlights more of the iris, allowing its full range of colors and patterns to be seen more clearly.

Biological Eye Color Changes

While many perceived changes in eye color are optical illusions, genuine biological alterations can occur due to various processes or external factors affecting the iris’s structure or pigment.

One common instance involves infant eye color development. Many babies are born with light blue or gray eyes because their melanocytes, the cells producing melanin, have not yet fully activated due to limited light exposure in the womb. As infants are exposed to light, melanin production increases and stabilizes, often causing their eye color to darken to green, hazel, or brown, typically settling by 6 to 9 months or up to three years of age.

Medical Conditions

Horner’s syndrome: A rare neurological condition, it can cause a lighter iris in affected children under two due to reduced melanin production.
Fuchs heterochromic iridocyclitis: This chronic inflammatory condition can result in depigmentation and lightening of the iris, often subtly over years.
Pigmentary glaucoma: Involves pigment loss from the iris’s back surface, which can clog the eye’s drainage system and potentially lighten parts of the iris.
Uveitis: Inflammation within the eye can also lead to changes in iris appearance or color.

Medications, particularly prostaglandin analogs used to treat glaucoma, are known to cause a gradual and permanent darkening of eye color. These eye drops increase melanin production in the iris, often shifting lighter eyes (blue, green, or hazel) towards a brown shade over several months to years. Trauma to the eye, such as severe injury or surgery, can also physically disrupt the iris, leading to tissue loss or changes in its appearance and color.

Heterochromia, a condition where an individual has two different colored eyes or multiple colors within one eye, can be present from birth (congenital) or acquired later in life. Congenital heterochromia is often harmless, stemming from genetic variations affecting melanin levels. Acquired heterochromia can result from injuries, certain medical conditions, or the use of specific medications.