Why Are Staples Used Instead of Stitches?

Surgical wound closure is fundamental to medical procedures, bringing tissue edges together to promote healing and minimize complications. Surgical staples and sutures are two widely used techniques, chosen based on various medical factors.

Surgical Staples: Design and Function

Surgical staples are fasteners made from medical-grade metals like titanium or stainless steel. Applied with a stapler device, they quickly and efficiently close skin or internal tissues. Their B-shaped design compresses tissue, and some staplers include a blade for a clean closure.

Different staplers exist: linear for connecting tissue or removing organs, circular for joining internal tube-like organs, and skin staplers for external wound closure. Skin staplers are useful for areas under significant tension, such as the scalp. Staples offer uniform closure, enhancing wound approximation strength and consistency.

Surgical Sutures: Design and Function

Surgical sutures, or stitches, consist of a medical thread attached to a needle, used to hold body tissues together. Threads are made from natural fibers like silk or synthetics such as nylon, polypropylene, or polydioxanone. The needle passes through tissue, allowing precise wound closure.

Sutures are categorized as absorbable or non-absorbable. Absorbable sutures degrade and are absorbed by the body, eliminating removal. Non-absorbable sutures remain in place unless surgically removed, used for long-term support or external skin closure. Techniques include continuous sutures (single thread) or interrupted sutures (each stitch tied individually).

Factors Influencing Closure Method Selection

The choice between surgical staples and sutures depends on factors unique to each patient and wound. Wound characteristics like size, depth, and location play a significant role. Staples are chosen for long incisions or high-tension areas (e.g., abdomen, scalp) due to their speed and strength. Sutures offer greater precision for delicate or irregularly shaped wounds, suitable for areas like the face where a fine closure is desired.

Staples offer speed and efficiency, closing wounds faster than sutures, beneficial in emergencies or lengthy procedures. While staples provide strong closure, sutures allow for more meticulous tissue alignment, potentially leading to a finer cosmetic outcome, especially in visible areas. Staples may have a lower infection risk in some orthopedic or abdominal procedures due to less foreign material and reduced tissue trauma. However, infection risk depends on proper wound care for both methods. A surgeon’s preference and patient-specific factors like skin type and health conditions contribute to the final decision.

Post-Procedure Healing and Management

Proper post-procedure care is important for healing and minimizing complications. This involves keeping the incision clean and dry for the initial 24 to 48 hours. After this, gentle washing with mild soap and water is recommended, followed by patting dry. Patients should avoid soaking the wound in baths or swimming until healing progresses.

Pain management after staples or sutures can be addressed with over-the-counter pain relievers. A main difference is their removal. Non-absorbable sutures and staples require professional removal once the wound has healed, usually within 1 to 3 weeks, depending on location and healing rate. Absorbable sutures dissolve naturally within the body, eliminating removal. Scarring is an expected outcome with both methods, but factors like individual skin type and wound tension significantly influence the final appearance. Healthcare providers provide guidance on signs of complications, such as increased redness, swelling, pus, or excessive pain, which warrant immediate medical attention.