Why Are My Tomatoes Cracking on Top?

Tomatoes are a popular garden crop, but cracks on the fruit’s shoulder can be frustrating. This splitting of the tomato’s outer skin is a common physiological disorder, not a disease or pest problem. It occurs when the fruit’s internal growth rate exceeds the skin’s ability to stretch, driven primarily by inconsistent water availability. While cracked tomatoes are often unsightly, understanding this mechanism is the first step toward managing this frequent garden challenge.

The Mechanism Behind Tomato Fruit Cracking

Tomato fruit cracking results from an imbalance between the fruit’s pulp expansion and the skin’s tensile strength. The process begins when dry weather or irregular watering causes the plant to conserve moisture, making the fruit’s skin toughen and lose elasticity. If this dry spell is suddenly followed by a heavy influx of water (from aggressive irrigation or a significant rainstorm), the plant rapidly absorbs the moisture. This sudden water uptake causes the interior pulp cells to swell quickly, increasing internal pressure dramatically. The inelastic outer skin cannot accommodate the rapid expansion, causing it to split, usually concentrating the stress near the stem end. Fruits nearing maturity are particularly susceptible because skin elasticity naturally decreases as the tomato ripens.

Radial Versus Concentric Cracking

Tomato cracking presents in two distinct patterns, which help determine the timing and severity of the moisture stress event. Radial cracking appears as splits that radiate outward from the stem attachment point, resembling the spokes of a wheel. This damage is caused by a single, severe, and immediate surge of water uptake, often occurring when the tomato is nearly ripe. Concentric cracking forms a series of circular rings concentrated around the stem end of the fruit. These cracks result from slower, less extreme fluctuations in soil moisture or prolonged periods of heat stress during development. Both types compromise the fruit’s structural integrity.

Essential Strategies for Prevention

Preventing tomato cracking relies fundamentally on stabilizing the soil moisture around the plant’s root zone. The most effective strategy is implementing a deep, regular watering schedule that avoids the feast-or-famine cycle of dry soil followed by saturation. Aim to keep the soil consistently moist but never soggy, which often translates to a thorough soaking once or twice a week, depending on temperature and soil type.

Mulching and Variety Selection

Applying a thick layer of organic mulch, such as straw or shredded leaves, is another highly effective measure. Mulch helps regulate soil temperature and significantly reduces water evaporation, minimizing the rapid moisture fluctuations that trigger cracking. Gardeners can also select crack-resistant varieties, like certain hybrids, which have been bred to possess greater skin elasticity and are less prone to splitting than many large heirloom types.

Adjusting Harvest Timing

Adjusting harvest timing can mitigate losses, especially for susceptible varieties. Harvesting fruit at the “breaker” stage—when the color first begins to change from green to pink or yellow—and allowing it to finish ripening indoors reduces the time the fruit spends on the vine exposed to unpredictable weather. Harvesting immediately when a crack is first observed prevents further expansion of the injury and limits the chance of rot.

Are Cracked Tomatoes Still Edible?

A newly cracked tomato is generally safe to eat, provided the split is recent and the fruit is harvested immediately. The internal flesh remains perfectly fine, and the damaged portion can simply be cut away before consumption. However, the open wound created by the crack provides a direct entry point for airborne mold spores, bacteria, and fruit flies. If the crack has begun to show signs of healing, darkening, or is visibly contaminated with mold or insects, the tomato should be discarded. Cracked fruit is not recommended for home canning or preserving due to the uncertainty of bacterial exposure, but it is perfectly acceptable for immediate use in sauces, soups, or salsas where the appearance is not a concern.