Who Performs Spinal Surgery? Orthopedic vs. Neurosurgeon

Spinal surgery encompasses a variety of interventions designed to address the spine, spinal cord, and associated nerves. Procedures range from minimally invasive discectomies to complex spinal fusions and deformity corrections. When conditions like a herniated disc, spinal stenosis, or a spinal tumor require surgical treatment, patients encounter one of two highly trained medical specialists. These two distinct but overlapping groups of physicians perform the majority of complex spinal operations, and the choice often depends on the specific nature of the issue.

The Primary Surgical Specialists

The two main types of physicians who perform spinal surgery are Orthopedic Spine Surgeons (OSS) and Neurosurgeons (NS). Orthopedic Spine Surgeons complete a full residency in orthopedic surgery, focusing on the musculoskeletal system, followed by a specialized spine fellowship. Their practice involves the bones, joints, ligaments, and tendons, concentrating specialized training on the spine and its immediate structures. Neurosurgeons complete a neurosurgery residency, training them extensively in the central and peripheral nervous system, including the brain, spinal cord, and peripheral nerves. For most common degenerative spinal conditions, both types of fellowship-trained surgeons are considered equally qualified.

Understanding the Distinction Between Specialties

The difference between these two specialists lies primarily in their initial residency training and historical focus, which informs their approach to spinal problems. An orthopedic surgeon undergoes a five-year residency dedicated to the musculoskeletal system, gaining broad experience in biomechanics, trauma, and structural reconstruction. They then complete an additional one-year spine fellowship, honing their skills specifically for spinal procedures. This background often leads orthopedic spine surgeons to handle a large volume of spinal deformity corrections, such as scoliosis, and complex trauma cases.

The neurosurgery residency is six to seven years long and provides deep exposure to the brain, spinal cord, and nerve-related procedures. Neurosurgeons specializing in the spine also pursue a specialized fellowship, giving them a natural emphasis on the delicate neural structures. This training makes them the traditional choice for issues directly involving the spinal cord, such as intradural tumors or complex cysts, which require working inside the dura mater. Despite these subtle historical differences, for the majority of common degenerative spine surgeries, like fusions and decompressions, the training pathways have converged, leading to significant overlap in expertise.

The Supporting Operating Room Team

Spinal surgery requires a cohesive team working alongside the lead surgeon to ensure a safe and successful outcome. The Anesthesiologist or Certified Registered Nurse Anesthetist (CRNA) manages the patient’s anesthesia and monitors vital signs throughout the procedure. They administer medications to maintain stability and ensure the patient is pain-free and comfortable, and they are responsible for the patient’s immediate post-operative recovery from the anesthesia.

A surgical Physician Assistant (PA) or Nurse Practitioner (NP) often acts as the first assistant, working directly with the surgeon to assist with tissue handling, controlling bleeding, and closing the surgical site. Surgical technologists, also known as scrub techs, maintain the sterile field and meticulously organize and hand instruments to the surgeon. Specialized neuromonitoring technicians continuously track nerve function in real-time, providing immediate feedback to help prevent nerve injury during delicate maneuvers.

Non-Surgical Providers in Spine Care

Several non-surgical providers are integral to a patient’s spine care journey, both before surgery is considered and during recovery.

Key Non-Surgical Specialists

  • Physiatrists: These Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation specialists are medical doctors focused on diagnosing and treating conditions affecting function. They specialize in non-surgical rehabilitation, often prescribing physical therapy and performing diagnostic nerve studies like electromyography (EMG) to pinpoint the source of nerve pain.
  • Pain Management Specialists: Often anesthesiologists or physiatrists with fellowship training, they focus on interventional procedures to manage chronic pain. They perform targeted injections, such as epidural steroid injections or nerve blocks, and advanced therapies like radiofrequency ablation to directly interrupt pain signals.
  • Physical Therapists (PTs): These practitioners develop customized exercise programs to restore strength, mobility, and function, serving as the foundation of conservative care and post-operative recovery.
  • Neurologists: They may be involved in complex cases to diagnose conditions primarily affecting the nervous system, offering a specialized perspective before a surgical decision is made.