Who Cannot Donate Eyes? Medical Disqualifications

Eye donation involves giving corneal tissue, sclera, and other ocular tissues after death to restore sight for individuals with corneal blindness or for research purposes. This selfless act can significantly improve someone’s quality of life, allowing them to regain vision and independence. While eligibility for eye donation is broader than many people realize, specific medical criteria determine who can donate. Understanding these criteria helps clarify the process and encourages potential donors.

Common Misconceptions About Eye Donation

A common misconception is that age prevents donation; however, there is no upper age limit, as corneal health at the time of death is what matters. Corneal tissue from donors in their seventies or eighties can still be successfully transplanted. Poor eyesight, such as needing glasses, or conditions like cataracts, glaucoma, and astigmatism, do not usually prevent donation. These conditions typically affect other parts of the eye, not the cornea, which is the primary tissue used for sight-restoring transplants.

Diabetes does not automatically disqualify a person from donating their eyes. While severe insulin-dependent diabetes might lead to eyes being used for research, diet-controlled diabetes generally poses no barrier. Most forms of cancer also do not prevent eye donation. Exceptions include blood cancers like leukemia and lymphoma, or active cancers that have spread to the eye, due to concerns about disease transmission.

Absolute Medical Exclusions for Eye Donation

Certain medical conditions prevent eye donation to protect the recipient and ensure tissue viability. Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV/AIDS) and active Hepatitis B or C infections are disqualifiers due to the risk of transmitting these viral diseases. While modern testing has advanced, the potential for transmission through tissue remains a serious concern for these conditions. Creutzfeldt-Jakob Disease (CJD) or other prion diseases are also absolute exclusions, as these neurological conditions involve infectious proteins transmissible through tissue.

Active systemic infections, such as sepsis, meningitis, or viral encephalitis, also disqualify a donor. The presence of widespread infection introduces a risk of bacterial or fungal transmission to the recipient. Specific blood cancers, including leukemia and lymphoma, are absolute exclusions due to the potential for cancer cells to spread through donated tissue. Active eye infections or diseases directly affecting the cornea, such as retinoblastoma or malignant tumors, also prevent donation as they compromise the tissue.

Temporary or Conditional Exclusions

Some conditions or circumstances may temporarily prevent eye donation or require a detailed medical review. Active infections, other than those listed as absolute exclusions, might lead to temporary deferral until the infection is resolved or evaluated. Recent surgeries or medical treatments could also temporarily affect tissue viability, necessitating a case-by-case assessment by medical professionals. For instance, refractive surgeries like LASIK might affect corneal shape, making it unsuitable for standard transplants, though the tissue could still be used for research or different procedures.

Neurological conditions like multiple sclerosis, Parkinson’s disease, or Alzheimer’s often do not disqualify a person from eye donation, as they typically do not affect the cornea directly. However, some eye banks may require additional review or have specific policies regarding these conditions, especially if they are of unknown origin or involve the central nervous system. Ultimately, donation specialists conduct a thorough review of the deceased individual’s medical history to make the final determination. This detailed evaluation ensures the safety of the recipient and the suitability of the donated tissue for transplantation or research.