Who Arranged the Periodic Table by Atomic Number?

The periodic table provides a structured framework for understanding the chemical elements. Its design allows scientists to predict an element’s properties, such as how it will react with other substances or the type of compounds it might form. This arrangement is a profound chemical map that reflects the fundamental nature of matter. The system is built upon a specific, ordered sequence that makes the table invaluable for predicting chemical behavior.

The Early Foundation: Ordering by Atomic Mass

The first widely recognized and effective periodic system was developed by the Russian chemist Dmitri Mendeleev in 1869. Mendeleev, along with the German chemist Lothar Meyer who published a nearly identical system around the same time, based his arrangement primarily on the order of increasing atomic mass. This approach successfully grouped elements with similar chemical properties into the same columns, demonstrating a clear pattern of periodicity.

Mendeleev’s genius lay in his willingness to prioritize the grouping of similar properties over the strict ordering by mass. He famously left gaps in his table for elements that had not yet been discovered, accurately predicting the properties of these missing substances. However, adhering to chemical similarity forced him to make a few specific exceptions, placing certain elements out of the strict order of their atomic masses.

These “swapped” pairs represented an anomaly in the mass-based system. For instance, Tellurium has a slightly higher atomic mass than Iodine, but Mendeleev placed Tellurium before Iodine so that Iodine could be correctly grouped with the chemically similar Halogens. These necessary inversions suggested that atomic mass was not the true basis for the periodic law. The underlying organizing principle of the elements remained elusive and required a more fundamental atomic property than mass.

Identifying the True Ordering Principle

The scientist who ultimately solved this mystery and established the arrangement based on increasing atomic number was the English physicist Henry Moseley. Working in Ernest Rutherford’s laboratory in 1913, Moseley conducted a series of experiments using X-ray spectroscopy. He bombarded samples of different elements with high-speed electrons, causing them to emit characteristic X-rays.

Moseley found that the frequency of the emitted X-rays had a precise mathematical relationship to an element’s position in the periodic table. By analyzing the X-ray spectra of nearly 40 different elements, he determined that the square root of the X-ray frequency was proportional to a whole number, which he called the atomic number, represented by the symbol Z. This number was immediately recognized as the number of positive charges, or protons, in the atomic nucleus.

This discovery provided a fundamental, non-arbitrary physical basis for ordering the elements. Unlike atomic mass, which can vary due to the existence of different isotopes, the atomic number is a fixed quantity for every atom of a given element. Moseley’s work demonstrated that the chemical properties of an element are determined by this number of protons, not by its overall mass. The atomic number, therefore, replaced atomic mass as the defining characteristic and the true basis for the periodic arrangement.

Resolving the Periodic Table Anomalies

The application of Moseley’s atomic number principle immediately and elegantly resolved the historical inconsistencies in the mass-based periodic table. The earlier anomalies, which had forced Mendeleev to reverse the order of certain element pairs to maintain chemical groupings, vanished. When ordered by atomic number, those inverted pairs naturally fell into their correct positions.

For example, the anomaly of Tellurium (Te) and Iodine (I) was instantly corrected. Tellurium has an atomic mass higher than Iodine’s, but Tellurium has an atomic number of 52, while Iodine has an atomic number of 53. Ordering by the number of protons (52 then 53) correctly places Tellurium in the oxygen family and Iodine in the halogen family, aligning perfectly with their known chemical behaviors.

Similar inversions, such as those between Argon (Ar, Z=18) and Potassium (K, Z=19), and Cobalt (Co, Z=27) and Nickel (Ni, Z=28), were also resolved. The consistency provided by the atomic number validated the structure of the modern periodic table and proved that the number of protons is the property responsible for the chemical identity and periodicity of the elements.