Which Takes More Muscles: Smiling or Frowning?

A common question asks whether smiling or frowning uses more muscles. This query delves into the intricate mechanics of human facial expressions, fundamental to our communication and emotional display. Exploring the specific muscles involved reveals the biological complexity behind facial expressions. Understanding the anatomy of a smile and a frown provides insight into how our faces convey a range of feelings.

The Anatomy of a Smile

A smile, whether subtle or broad, involves several facial muscles. The zygomaticus major pulls the corners of the mouth upward, extending from the cheekbone to the mouth corner. This muscle is important for forming most types of smiles. The risorius muscle also contributes by pulling the mouth corners sideways.

For a more expansive smile, other muscles become active. The orbicularis oculi, surrounding the eye, contracts to raise the cheeks and create “crow’s feet” wrinkles. This combined action with the zygomaticus major defines a Duchenne smile, often considered a true smile of enjoyment. Other muscles, such as the levator labii superioris, elevate the upper lip, while the buccinator pulls the cheeks back, contributing to a wider smile.

The Anatomy of a Frown

Frowning engages a distinct set of facial muscles, affecting the forehead and mouth. The corrugator supercilii muscles draw the eyebrows together and downwards, producing vertical lines. Its action can also shield the eyes from bright light.

The procerus pulls the skin between the eyebrows downwards, creating horizontal wrinkles across the bridge of the nose. The depressor anguli oris muscle pulls down the corners of the mouth. The depressor labii inferioris lowers the bottom lip.

The Verdict and Nuance

The belief that frowning requires significantly more muscles than smiling is largely a misconception. While the exact number of muscles involved can vary based on the intensity and specific type of expression, scientific consensus suggests that smiling typically uses a comparable or even slightly greater number of muscles than frowning.

For instance, a basic smile that raises only the corners of the lips and upper lip can involve around five muscle pairs, or ten muscles in total. In contrast, a minimal frown, achieved by lowering the corners of the mouth, might involve three muscle pairs, or six muscles.

A more complex, genuine smile, a Duchenne smile, engages additional muscles like the orbicularis oculi around the eyes, adding to the total muscle count. A polite or social smile, in contrast, often relies primarily on the zygomaticus major without engaging the eye muscles.

Some sources suggest that frowning may require around 11 muscles, whereas smiling could involve 12. The precise count is challenging to determine definitively due to the wide range of expressions and individual variations in facial musculature. Ultimately, the complexity of the expression, rather than its positive or negative nature, dictates the number of muscles engaged.