Which Is Worse: Strep A or Strep B?

Streptococcus is a common type of bacteria, characterized by its spherical shape and tendency to form chains. While many species are harmless, certain types cause a range of infections, from mild to severe. Group A Streptococcus and Group B Streptococcus are two significant types that can lead to serious health concerns.

Understanding Group A Streptococcus

Group A Streptococcus (Streptococcus pyogenes) causes various common human infections. These include “strep throat” (pharyngitis), skin infections like impetigo and cellulitis, and scarlet fever. Strep throat often presents with a sore throat, fever, and swollen tonsils. Impetigo causes red, crusting sores, while cellulitis leads to skin redness and swelling.

While many Group A Strep infections are mild, the bacteria can lead to severe complications if they invade deeper tissues or the bloodstream. This is known as invasive Group A Streptococcal disease (iGAS). Severe forms include necrotizing fasciitis, or “flesh-eating disease,” which rapidly destroys tissue. Streptococcal toxic shock syndrome (STSS) is another life-threatening condition causing organ failure and dangerously low blood pressure.

Beyond acute infections, Group A Strep can trigger immune-mediated complications, or “post-infectious sequelae,” even after the initial infection clears. These are due to the body’s immune response, not the bacteria directly. Examples include acute rheumatic fever, which can damage the heart, joints, and nervous system, potentially leading to rheumatic heart disease. Post-streptococcal glomerulonephritis, affecting the kidneys, is another complication.

While mild infections are common in children, severe invasive Group A Strep infections can affect anyone. Older adults, immunocompromised individuals, and those with chronic conditions or skin injuries face a higher risk.

Understanding Group B Streptococcus

Group B Streptococcus (Streptococcus agalactiae) commonly resides in the intestines and lower genital tract of healthy individuals without causing illness. In adults, it can cause urinary tract infections. Its primary concern, however, is with pregnant women and newborns, where it can lead to severe, life-threatening conditions.

During pregnancy, Group B Strep can cause infections of the placenta, amniotic fluid, or the uterine lining after childbirth. The most significant risk is to newborns who acquire the bacteria during labor and delivery. Infected infants can develop serious conditions like sepsis (blood infection), meningitis, or pneumonia.

Neonatal infections are categorized into early-onset disease, appearing within the first week of life, and late-onset disease, manifesting from seven days up to several months after birth. While healthy adults generally do not experience severe illness, other populations are susceptible. These include the elderly, individuals with chronic medical conditions like diabetes, heart disease, or cancer, and those with weakened immune systems.

Comparing the Impact and Severity

Both Group A and Group B Streptococcus can cause significant harm, but their impact differs. Group A Streptococcus is known for common, often mild infections like strep throat. However, its rare invasive forms, such as necrotizing fasciitis and streptococcal toxic shock syndrome, are acutely life-threatening and can progress rapidly.

Mortality rates for severe invasive Group A Strep infections are substantial. Necrotizing fasciitis has a mortality rate of approximately 20-30%, and streptococcal toxic shock syndrome ranges from 50-60%. These cases, though less common, are dangerous due to rapid onset and high fatality. The incidence of invasive Group A Strep has recently increased, particularly among adults and vulnerable populations like the elderly or those with chronic illnesses.

Conversely, Group B Streptococcus is primarily a concern for newborns. While many pregnant women carry the bacteria, preventive measures during labor have significantly reduced early-onset neonatal disease. However, neonatal Group B Strep infections, if they occur, can be severe, leading to sepsis, meningitis, and pneumonia in infants, with a mortality rate of about 5% even with treatment.

The severity of Group B Strep in adults is generally lower than invasive Group A Strep, often causing urinary tract infections. However, it can still lead to serious conditions like sepsis, pneumonia, or bone infections in older adults or those with weakened immune systems. Group A Strep has the potential for rapid, highly fatal invasive disease in a broader population. Group B Strep’s disproportionate impact on newborns, alongside its risks to other vulnerable adults, highlights its distinct threat.

Diagnosis and Management

Accurate and timely diagnosis is important for managing both Group A and Group B Streptococcus infections. For Group A Strep, especially suspected strep throat, diagnosis often involves a rapid antigen detection test (RADT) or a throat culture. For more severe or invasive Group A Strep infections, blood tests or tissue samples may be collected for laboratory analysis.

Group B Strep in pregnant women is typically diagnosed through routine screening, involving vaginal and rectal swabs in the third trimester. If an active infection is suspected in adults or newborns, samples of blood, urine, or spinal fluid may be cultured to identify the bacteria.

Both Group A and Group B Streptococcus are bacterial infections, primarily treated with antibiotics. Penicillin is a common and effective choice for both. For individuals with penicillin allergies, alternative antibiotics are available. Early diagnosis and appropriate antibiotic treatment prevent the progression of infections and reduce the risk of severe complications, regardless of the specific streptococcal type.