Which Is Poisonous: A Frog or a Toad?

Many people wonder if frogs or toads are poisonous, often assuming only one type poses a risk. Both frogs and toads can possess defensive toxins, chemical compounds produced in their skin as a protective mechanism against predators. This article clarifies the nature of amphibian toxicity and provides practical safety information.

Distinguishing Frogs from Toads

Frogs and toads, both belonging to the order Anura, exhibit several physical differences. Frogs typically have smooth, moist, or slimy skin, which often appears shiny. Their bodies are slender, with long hind legs designed for powerful jumping and swimming. Frogs tend to prefer habitats near water, as their skin requires moisture to facilitate breathing.

In contrast, toads usually feature dry, bumpy, warty skin, which helps them retain moisture in drier environments. They possess a more stout and squat body shape, with shorter legs suited for walking or short hops. Toads are often found in terrestrial habitats, venturing further from water than most frogs.

The Nature of Amphibian Toxicity

Amphibians produce toxins as a defense against predators. Their toxicity originates from specialized skin glands, such as granular glands or larger parotoid glands found behind the eyes in many toads. These glands secrete various chemical compounds, including bufadienolides in toads or potent neurotoxins like batrachotoxins in some frogs. When a predator attempts to consume or mouth these amphibians, toxins are released, causing irritation or more severe effects.

An animal is considered poisonous if its toxins are harmful when ingested, inhaled, or absorbed through the skin. Most frogs and toads are poisonous, relying on passive contact or ingestion of their skin secretions for defense. Venomous animals, conversely, actively inject toxins, typically through a bite or sting. While rare, a few frog species are venomous, possessing specialized structures to deliver their toxins.

Identifying Potentially Dangerous Species

Many amphibians are not highly toxic to humans, though their secretions can cause irritation. Some species are more dangerous due to toxin potency. A common indicator of potential danger is aposematic coloration: bright, conspicuous colors or patterns that serve as a warning signal to predators.

Highly toxic species, such as the vibrant poison dart frogs from Central and South America, display these warning colors. The Golden Poison Frog (Phyllobates terribilis), for instance, secretes a potent neurotoxin called batrachotoxin, which can be lethal. Certain toad species, like the Cane Toad (Rhinella marina), also produce powerful bufadienolides that can cause serious illness or death, especially in pets. Always avoid handling any wild amphibian to prevent accidental exposure to their defensive skin secretions.

Safety and First Aid

If you encounter a wild frog or toad, observe it without touching to prevent accidental toxin exposure. Pet owners should keep curious dogs and cats away from amphibians, especially during warmer, wetter months when they are more active. Clean outdoor food and water bowls daily to prevent residual toxin accumulation.

If contact with an amphibian’s secretions occurs, take immediate action. For humans, thoroughly wash hands with soap and water; if secretions enter the eyes or mouth, flush with copious amounts of water for 15 to 20 minutes. For pets, if they mouth or lick a toad, wipe their mouth and gums immediately with a wet cloth, avoiding a hose to prevent water aspiration. Seek medical attention for humans or veterinary care for pets if symptoms develop, such as excessive drooling, vomiting, disorientation, or seizures, as some toxins can rapidly affect the heart and nervous system.