Which Bears Do You Play Dead For? And When to Fight Back

An encounter with a bear in the wild can be frightening, but knowing how to react can improve the outcome. The appropriate response depends on the bear species and the nature of the encounter. Understanding bear types and their behaviors is important for safety.

Recognizing Bear Types

Distinguishing bear species is important because response strategies vary. In North America, humans primarily encounter Black Bears and Grizzly (Brown) Bears. Grizzly Bears have a noticeable shoulder hump, a dished facial profile, and shorter, rounded ears. Their front claws are long (2-4.5 inches) and gently curved, aiding in digging.

Black Bears, in contrast, lack a prominent shoulder hump and have a straight facial profile. Their ears are larger, more pointed, and more erect than a grizzly’s. Black Bear claws are shorter (less than 2 inches) and more sharply curved, making them efficient tree climbers. While color is misleading, as both vary in hue, these physical characteristics offer more reliable identification cues.

When to Play Dead

Playing dead is a recommended strategy primarily for defensive encounters with Grizzly (Brown) Bears. This response is appropriate when a grizzly perceives you as a threat, such as if you surprise it or if a mother bear is protecting cubs. This aims to convince the bear you are no longer a danger, reducing its aggression.

To play dead, immediately lie flat on your stomach, spreading your legs slightly to make it harder for the bear to roll you over. Clasp your hands behind your neck for protection. If wearing a backpack, keep it on for back protection. Remain still and silent until certain the bear has left, which may take several minutes. If a defensive attack from a grizzly persists, fighting back vigorously becomes necessary.

When to Fight Back

Fighting back is the recommended response for attacks by Black Bears or any predatory attack by any bear species. If a Black Bear charges or attacks, playing dead is not advisable, as it may intensify the attack. Black Bears are more timid, and an aggressive defense can deter them.

In such situations, act boldly by yelling, making yourself appear as large as possible, and using any available objects as weapons. Target sensitive areas such as the bear’s face, eyes, and nose with kicks, punches, or strikes from sticks or rocks. The goal is to show you are not easy prey and make the bear retreat. If a bear exhibits predatory behavior, such as stalking or persistent approach, fight back regardless of species.

Avoiding Bear Encounters

Preventing bear encounters is the safest approach in bear country. Make noise while hiking, especially in areas with limited visibility like dense brush or near noisy streams. Talking loudly, clapping, or periodically calling out “Hey, bear!” can alert bears to your presence, giving them time to move away. Hiking in groups of three or more people also reduces the likelihood of an attack, as groups are more intimidating to bears.

Carrying bear spray and knowing how to use it is a key safety measure. Bear spray, an EPA-approved product containing capsaicin, should be readily accessible, ideally in a holster on your belt or chest. When camping, store food and scented items in bear-resistant containers, locked vehicles, or suspended from trees at least 10 feet off the ground and 4 feet from the trunk. Never store food or scented products inside your tent, as bears have an excellent sense of smell and can be attracted to these items.