When Should You Start Dialysis for Kidney Failure?

The decision to begin dialysis is a significant moment for individuals facing severe kidney failure, marking the start of a life-sustaining treatment. Dialysis cleans the blood by removing excess fluid, waste products, and toxins, a function the kidneys can no longer perform. This treatment is necessary when a patient reaches End-Stage Kidney Disease (ESKD). The timing is highly complex and individualized, relying on a combination of specific medical measurements and the patient’s physical well-being, not a single number. The goal is to start treatment when it provides the greatest benefit, requiring close monitoring and shared decision-making with a specialist physician.

Understanding Severe Kidney Failure

Kidneys naturally filter the entire blood volume numerous times each day, balancing electrolytes and removing metabolic waste products. When these organs fail, the body cannot effectively manage fluid volume or eliminate substances like urea and creatinine, leading to a toxic buildup called uremia. This progressive decline is tracked through stages of Chronic Kidney Disease (CKD), culminating in Stage 5, also known as ESKD.

Stage 5 CKD signifies that the kidneys are operating at less than 15% of their normal capacity. The primary tool doctors use to track this decline is the Glomerular Filtration Rate (GFR), an estimated measurement that calculates how well the kidney’s filtering units are working. GFR effectively represents the percentage of kidney function remaining. While GFR is a critical metric, it provides only one part of the picture when deciding the appropriate time to start treatment.

Primary Medical Criteria for Starting Dialysis

The most common quantitative benchmark for considering dialysis is when the estimated GFR falls below 15 mL/min/1.73m\(^2\). This corresponds to Stage 5 kidney failure, signifying that the kidneys are functioning at 10% to 15% of normal capacity. However, recent clinical evidence suggests that for patients without significant symptoms, safely delaying the start of dialysis is often possible under close medical supervision.

In stable, asymptomatic patients, dialysis may be postponed until the GFR drops to a lower range, sometimes even down to 5 to 7 mL/min/1.73m\(^2\). The decision is often forced by laboratory abnormalities that pose an immediate threat to life, regardless of the GFR number. These mandatory triggers include dangerously high potassium levels (hyperkalemia) that cannot be controlled with medication, which can cause abnormal heart rhythms.

Another urgent criterion is severe acidosis, a condition where the blood becomes too acidic. Uncontrolled fluid overload, leading to pulmonary edema or dangerously high blood pressure that resists all other treatments, also mandates an immediate start to therapy. In these cases, the lab results and the immediate threat to the patient’s health override any consideration of a slightly higher GFR.

Symptomatic Triggers and Individualized Timing

The most frequent reason for starting dialysis is the onset of severe, debilitating symptoms associated with uremia, the buildup of wastes and toxins in the blood. These symptoms often prompt treatment even if the GFR is slightly above the traditional 15 mL/min/1.73m\(^2\) mark. The symptoms themselves are often the most reliable indicator that the body can no longer sustain itself without mechanical support.

Severe fatigue and weakness are common complaints, often described as overwhelming, making simple daily tasks nearly impossible. Patients often experience persistent nausea, vomiting, a metallic taste in the mouth, and significant loss of appetite, which can lead to severe malnutrition. When fluid retention cannot be managed by diuretics, it can cause peripheral swelling (edema) or, more seriously, fluid in the lungs (pulmonary edema), leading to shortness of breath.

Cognitive impairment, known as uremic encephalopathy, is another serious sign, manifesting as trouble with mental focus, confusion, or memory issues. In rare but serious instances, uremia can cause inflammation of the sac surrounding the heart, a condition called uremic pericarditis, which is a near-absolute indication for immediate treatment. A patient’s existing health conditions, such as diabetes or heart disease, may also lead doctors to recommend an earlier start to prevent complications, making the decision a shared one tailored to the individual’s quality of life.

Preparing for Dialysis

Once the decision to start dialysis is made, significant logistical steps must be taken well in advance of the first treatment. A crucial and time-sensitive preparation is the creation of a durable vascular access site for hemodialysis, which is the most common form of treatment. The preferred method is an arteriovenous (AV) fistula, a surgical connection between an artery and a vein, which requires several months to mature and strengthen before it can be used.

If a patient’s vessels are unsuitable, a synthetic arteriovenous graft may be placed, which also requires a healing period. These permanent access options are preferred over a temporary central venous catheter, which has a higher risk of infection and is typically only used when dialysis must begin urgently. For patients choosing peritoneal dialysis, a catheter must be surgically placed in the abdomen, which also needs time to heal before it can be used for exchanges.

During this preparatory period, the patient and their family receive extensive education from a dedicated care team, which includes a nephrologist, nurses, dietitians, and social workers. This training covers necessary dietary and fluid restrictions, the chosen treatment modality, and the practicalities of scheduling. Planning ahead for access surgery and education is paramount to ensure a safe, smooth, and timely transition to life-sustaining therapy.