When Buttock Implants Go Wrong: How Common Are They?

Buttock augmentation is a cosmetic procedure sought by individuals aiming to enhance the size, shape, and contour of their gluteal region. The desire for a more voluminous or defined posterior has driven significant interest in body contouring surgeries worldwide. These procedures offer a lasting solution for patients who feel their natural silhouette is disproportionate or lacking projection.

Statistical Popularity and Trends

The appeal for buttock augmentation procedures has grown substantially over the last decade, reflecting a broader shift in aesthetic ideals. In 2023, the combined total of buttock augmentation procedures, including implants and fat transfer, was estimated at nearly 30,000.

The overwhelming majority of these augmentations are performed using autologous fat transfer, commonly known as the Brazilian Butt Lift (BBL). Buttock implants account for a significantly smaller segment of the market, representing only about 4% of all buttock augmentation procedures nationally. The demographic seeking these enhancements is often younger, with Millennials accounting for a high percentage of those undergoing fat grafting procedures.

Distinguishing Augmentation Methods

A clear distinction exists between the legitimate surgical approaches to buttock enhancement and dangerous, unsanctioned methods. The two primary, medically recognized techniques are solid silicone implants and autologous fat transfer.

Buttock implants involve the surgical placement of a pre-shaped, semi-solid silicone prosthetic deep within or above the gluteus maximus muscle. This method is typically chosen by patients with minimal body fat who cannot provide enough donor material for a fat transfer.

The Brazilian Butt Lift (BBL) utilizes liposuction to harvest a patient’s own fat from areas like the abdomen or flanks, which is then purified and injected into the buttocks. This technique carries the advantage of simultaneously contouring a second area of the body while using natural tissue for the augmentation.

These methods stand in sharp contrast to illegal injectable fillers, such as liquid silicone or hydrogel, which are not medically sanctioned for large-scale body contouring. The use of liquid silicone is particularly dangerous and is not approved by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA). Unlike the contained silicone in a solid implant, injected liquid silicone can migrate freely throughout the body, leading to catastrophic, systemic complications.

Specific Risks and Severe Complications

The risk profile differs significantly between the two legitimate procedures, and both carry specific complications. For buttock implants, complications often involve issues related to the foreign material itself.

Capsular contracture, where scar tissue tightens around the implant, can cause the buttock to feel abnormally firm or distorted, occurring in an estimated 5% to 10% of cases. Implant malposition, or displacement, affects approximately 3% to 5% of patients, requiring surgical repositioning.

Infection is a serious concern, as any foreign material placed in the body is susceptible, and a severe infection often necessitates the complete removal of the implant. In some instances, the implant may exert pressure on the sciatic nerve, resulting in chronic pain, numbness, or tingling that extends down the leg.

The most serious complication associated with the Brazilian Butt Lift is fat embolism, a life-threatening event. This occurs when injected fat enters the bloodstream and travels to the lungs or heart, causing a blockage. The BBL has been associated with one of the highest mortality rates in cosmetic surgery, estimated at approximately 1 in 3,000 procedures.

Beyond this severe risk, BBL patients may experience fat necrosis, where transferred fat cells die due to insufficient blood supply, leading to firm lumps or oil cysts. Asymmetry is also a common issue, affecting roughly 5% of patients due to unpredictable fat absorption rates. Furthermore, only about 60% to 80% of the transferred fat typically survives, leading to volume loss over time.

The consequences of illegal liquid injections are often the most devastating, as these substances are unregulated and highly inflammatory. Catastrophic outcomes include widespread infection, tissue death, permanent disfigurement, and the migration of the substance to distant organs, which can cause stroke or death.

Regulatory Landscape and Safety Precautions

The regulatory environment provides a framework for safety, though patient vigilance remains necessary. The FDA has explicitly warned consumers that injectable silicone for large-scale body contouring is not approved and is illegal. The warning highlights that complications from these unapproved liquids can be severe and long-lasting.

Professional societies have established strict guidelines to mitigate the highest risks associated with BBL procedures. Surgeons are advised to inject fat exclusively into the superficial fat layer above the muscle fascia to avoid the deep blood vessels where fat embolisms originate. Patients must prioritize choosing a board-certified plastic surgeon who operates in an accredited facility. Verifying a surgeon’s credentials and ensuring the facility meets safety standards are crucial steps in reducing the likelihood of severe complications.