What Was Wrong With the Lions of Tsavo?

The Tsavo Man-Eaters are a compelling chapter in human-wildlife interactions, captivating public imagination for over a century. Their story unfolds during colonial expansion in East Africa, marked by ambitious infrastructure projects. These two male lions became notorious for their predation on humans, disrupting railway construction and prompting widespread fear. Understanding the factors that drove this unprecedented behavior has been a subject of ongoing scientific investigation.

The Tsavo Incident

In March 1898, the British began constructing a railway bridge over the Tsavo River in Kenya, part of the larger Uganda Railway project aimed at connecting the Indian Ocean coast with inland Uganda. Thousands of workers, primarily from British India, were brought in to undertake this challenging endeavor, living in rudimentary camps spread across an eight-mile area. Lieutenant-Colonel John Henry Patterson, an engineer, arrived to oversee the bridge’s construction.

Soon after Patterson’s arrival, workers began disappearing from their tents at night, dragged away by predators. The attacks escalated, with the maneless lions growing increasingly bold. This period lasted for nine months, causing immense fear among laborers, some of whom fled the site, bringing construction to a near standstill. Patterson eventually took it upon himself to hunt the two lions, successfully killing the first in early December 1898 and the second a few weeks later.

Early Theories Behind the Man-Eating Behavior

Initial explanations for the Tsavo lions’ man-eating habits often centered on environmental factors and opportunistic behavior. One common theory suggested a lack of natural prey, possibly due to a severe rinderpest epidemic in the 1890s that decimated populations of cattle and wild ungulates like buffalo and wildebeest. This scarcity of typical food sources might have compelled the lions to seek alternative sustenance.

Another speculation proposed that the lions developed a taste for human flesh after scavenging on bodies. The Tsavo region was a historical transit route for slave caravans, and sick or deceased individuals were sometimes left behind, providing an accessible food source. Additionally, the railway construction brought a large influx of human workers, and diseases like cholera in the camps meant bodies might have been poorly interred, further habituating the lions to human remains. This repeated exposure could have led them to associate humans with an easy meal.

Modern Scientific Investigations and Findings

Modern scientific investigations provide detailed insights into why the Tsavo lions became man-eaters, moving beyond earlier conjectures. Stable isotope analysis of the lions’ bone collagen and hair keratin allowed researchers to reconstruct their diet. This analysis confirmed humans constituted a portion of their diet, with one lion showing a progressive dietary specialization on humans, consuming up to 30% of its diet from human prey in the months before its death. Estimates of the number of victims, while debated, range from 28 to 35, with some earlier claims of 135 being considered exaggerated by current research.

Examination of the lions’ remains, particularly their teeth, revealed an explanation for their unusual behavior. One Tsavo lion, the one that consumed more human prey, had severe dental disease, including a painful root-tip abscess in a canine. Such an injury would have made it difficult for the lion to hunt and subdue large, struggling natural prey like zebra or buffalo, which typically requires a strong bite to the neck or throat. Humans, being relatively easier to catch and subdue, would have presented a more manageable food source for an injured predator. The dental wear patterns on the Tsavo lions’ teeth were found to be similar to those of zoo lions fed soft foods, rather than the heavy wear expected from consistently crunching bones of wild prey.

Genomic studies, analyzing hair DNA embedded in the lions’ teeth, illuminated their diverse diet, which included giraffe, oryx, waterbuck, wildebeest, and zebra, alongside humans. The presence of wildebeest DNA was notable, suggesting either the lions traveled farther than previously thought or the historical distribution of wildebeest differed. These analyses show that while environmental factors like prey scarcity and the availability of human corpses likely played a role, physical infirmities, such as dental issues, were a primary driver for these lions to turn to human prey.

The Legacy of the Tsavo Lions

The story of the Tsavo Man-Eaters continues to resonate in public consciousness through various forms of media. Their preserved remains are prominently displayed at the Field Museum of Natural History in Chicago, Illinois, where they are a popular exhibit. Patterson sold the lions to the museum in 1925, and museum staff meticulously restored them from their initial state as trophy rugs. Their tale has inspired numerous books and films, including the 1996 Hollywood adaptation The Ghost and the Darkness, amplifying their legend.

Beyond popular culture, the Tsavo lions hold continued scientific importance. They serve as a unique case study for understanding predator behavior, human-wildlife conflict, and the impact of environmental changes on animal diets. Ongoing research, utilizing new technologies like DNA analysis, continues to uncover details about their lives and the circumstances that led to their man-eating habits.