What Is a Good Fungicide and How Do You Choose One?

A fungicide is a chemical or biological agent designed to kill parasitic fungi or inhibit their growth and reproduction. These products are widely used in agriculture and gardening to protect plants from diseases like rusts, mildews, and blights, which can severely reduce crop yield and quality. Efficacy depends entirely on the specific fungal pathogen, the host plant being treated, and the environmental conditions present. Making an informed choice requires understanding how these products work, recognizing the specific plant problem, and applying the chosen product correctly.

Classification by Action

Fungicides are categorized primarily by how they interact with the plant and the fungal pathogen, a process known as their mobility or phytomobility. One major group is contact fungicides, also referred to as protectants, which remain on the surface of the plant tissue where they are applied. These products form a protective barrier that must be in place before fungal spores germinate and penetrate the plant, meaning they are exclusively preventative. Because they are not absorbed, thorough coverage of all susceptible plant parts is necessary, and they can be washed off by rain or irrigation.

The other main category is systemic fungicides, which are absorbed into the plant tissue. Once absorbed, they move within the plant’s vascular system, offering internal protection and sometimes providing curative action against existing, early-stage infections. Most systemic fungicides are not truly translocated throughout the entire plant but are locally systemic, moving short distances, or acropetally, moving upward with the water flow in the xylem. This internal mobility protects new growth that emerges after application and makes the product more resistant to being washed away by rain.

The Mode of Action (MoA) describes the specific biochemical process the fungicide targets within the fungus. For example, some MoAs inhibit fungal respiration, while others damage the cell membrane or interfere with energy production. The Fungicide Resistance Action Committee (FRAC) assigns a numerical code to each MoA group, which is printed on product labels to guide users in resistance management. Contact fungicides often have a multi-site mode of action, attacking the fungus at several points, which gives them a low risk for resistance development. Systemic fungicides typically have a single-site MoA, making them more effective but placing them at a higher risk for resistance development over time.

Selection Criteria for Specific Plant Problems

The most important step in selecting a fungicide is accurately identifying the disease causing the problem, as fungicides are ineffective against bacterial or viral infections. Symptoms like yellowing or spotting can mimic issues caused by nutrient deficiencies or insect damage, so confirmation of a fungal pathogen is a prerequisite for treatment. Once the disease is confirmed, the product label must be checked to ensure it specifically lists the target disease and the host plant.

Fungicides vary in their spectrum of control, offering a choice between broad-spectrum and narrow-spectrum products. Broad-spectrum options, such as those containing sulfur or copper, are effective against a wide range of fungi, while narrow-spectrum products may only target a specific group, like the oomycetes. The decision between a preventative and a curative approach also influences selection; contact fungicides are used strictly before infection, while systemic types are chosen when early symptoms are present and a curative effect is desired.

The host plant’s nature also factors into the selection, particularly whether it is an ornamental or an edible crop. Products approved for organic use, such as copper and sulfur, are often acceptable for food crops, but chemical options must be checked for their pre-harvest interval (PHI) to ensure safety. Environmental impact is another consideration, as some fungicides have come under increased scrutiny for potential negative effects on human health and the ecosystem. Multi-site contact fungicides like copper and chlorothalonil are considered lower risk for resistance development, making them valuable partners in a disease management program.

Safe and Effective Application Methods

Successful fungicide application depends heavily on precise timing, thorough coverage, and following safety guidelines. The most effective time to apply most fungicides is preventatively, before the fungal spores have germinated and penetrated the plant tissue. For existing infections, a curative systemic fungicide must be applied as soon as possible after the first symptoms appear, typically within 24 to 72 hours of infection. Applications should be timed to avoid immediate rainfall, which can wash off contact products before they dry, and ideally should occur during cooler temperatures.

Achieving complete and uniform coverage is necessary, especially when using contact fungicides, which only protect the area they physically cover. For dense plant canopies, increasing the water volume used for spraying helps ensure the product reaches the lower leaves, where fungal diseases often begin. The product must be diluted exactly according to the label instructions, as using a lower-than-recommended rate can reduce efficacy and contribute to the development of fungicide resistance.

To manage the high risk of resistance associated with single-site systemic fungicides, it is necessary to rotate or tank-mix products with different MoA groups, identified by their FRAC codes. This practice prevents the fungal population from becoming dominant with strains that are resistant to a single mechanism. Personal protective equipment (PPE), which may include gloves, protective eyewear, and long sleeves, must be worn during mixing and application to minimize health risks. All application equipment should be calibrated regularly to ensure the correct volume is delivered, and any unused product must be stored or disposed of safely according to label directions.

Non-Chemical Disease Management Options

Before resorting to chemical fungicides, growers and gardeners should prioritize cultural practices, which are the first line of defense against fungal diseases. Cultural practices involve modifying the growing environment to make it less favorable for the pathogen and more favorable for the plant. Improving air circulation by pruning dense foliage or ensuring proper plant spacing helps the leaves dry quickly, as most fungal spores require leaf wetness for germination and infection.

Proper watering techniques, such as using drip irrigation or watering at the base of the plant, can also reduce the moisture on foliage and slow down the spread of disease. Sanitation is a simple yet effective practice that involves removing infected plant debris, such as fallen leaves or diseased fruit, from the area to reduce the source of fungal spores. Planting disease-resistant varieties when available is a long-term strategy that provides protection without the need for chemical intervention.

Biological controls represent another non-chemical option, utilizing beneficial microorganisms to fight fungal pathogens. Products containing organisms like Bacillus subtilis or species of Trichoderma can be applied to the plant or soil, where they compete with the harmful fungi for resources or actively inhibit their growth. These biological agents often offer multiple modes of action, which makes it less likely for the fungal pathogens to develop resistance to them. These methods, when combined, create an integrated approach that can significantly lower disease pressure and reduce the reliance on fungicides.