What Happens When a Fistula Stops Working?

An Arteriovenous (AV) Fistula is a surgically created connection between an artery and a vein, typically in the arm, designed to provide a robust access point for hemodialysis. This procedure allows for the high blood flow rates necessary to effectively filter the blood of a patient with kidney failure. The fistula works by channeling high-pressure arterial blood into the vein, which causes the vein to enlarge and thicken, a process called maturation. A working fistula offers the longest lifespan and the lowest risk of infection or clotting compared to other access methods. Failure of this reliable vascular access can interrupt life-sustaining dialysis treatments and significantly affect patient health.

Recognizing the Signs of Fistula Dysfunction

The most immediate and practical indicator of a healthy fistula is the presence of a “thrill” and a “bruit.” The thrill is a distinct buzzing or vibrating sensation felt when lightly touching the skin over the fistula, while the bruit is the whooshing sound heard with a stethoscope. Both are caused by the turbulent, rapid blood flow through the connection. A sudden absence or a noticeable weakening of the thrill or bruit is the most urgent warning sign that a blockage or clot may have formed, requiring immediate medical attention.

Other physical changes can signal poor function or impending failure. Swelling in the arm, hand, or even the face on the side of the fistula may indicate a blockage in the central veins that return blood to the heart. The skin over the fistula may also show discoloration, become cool to the touch, or exhibit pain and redness, which can be a sign of infection or an issue with blood flow to the hand. Patients may also experience problems during their dialysis sessions, such as excessive alarms on the machine due to poor blood flow or unusually prolonged bleeding from the needle sites after the treatment has ended. These subtle or sudden changes should be reported to the dialysis care team right away, as timely intervention can often salvage the access.

Underlying Reasons for Access Failure

The vast majority of fistula failures stem from a progressive narrowing of the blood vessel called stenosis. This narrowing is primarily caused by intimal hyperplasia, which is the thickening of the innermost layer of the blood vessel wall in response to the trauma and altered blood flow dynamics created by the surgical connection. The high pressure and flow from the artery damage the vein’s lining, prompting the body to send extra cells to the site, which eventually build up and restrict the blood pathway. Stenosis is the most common cause of both early and late fistula failure, often occurring at the point where the artery and vein are joined, known as the anastomosis.

When stenosis becomes severe enough, the reduced blood flow can lead to the formation of a blood clot, a condition known as thrombosis. Thrombosis represents the acute, complete failure of the fistula, where the clot completely blocks the vessel and stops all blood flow. Systemic factors like low blood pressure, dehydration, or a hypercoagulable state can also contribute to this clot formation, especially when a pre-existing stenosis is present.

Other Causes of Dysfunction

Less common, but still a concern, is the development of a localized infection, often presenting as warmth, redness, or discharge around the access site. Infection can compromise the integrity of the vessel wall and, if left untreated, can lead to serious systemic issues. Another distinct mechanism of dysfunction is Steal Syndrome, where a significant amount of blood is diverted, or “stolen,” by the low-resistance fistula away from the hand and fingers. This can result in a lack of oxygenated blood supply to the distal extremity, causing symptoms like pain, coolness, numbness, and, in severe cases, tissue damage.

Urgent Medical Response and Treatment Options

Once a dysfunctional fistula is suspected, medical professionals must act quickly to diagnose the issue and restore function. This process often starts with a physical examination of the thrill and bruit.

Diagnosis

The primary diagnostic tool is a Doppler Ultrasound, which uses sound waves to visualize the blood flow and locate the exact site and severity of any narrowing or blockage. If the ultrasound is inconclusive, an Angiography is performed, which involves injecting contrast dye to create a clear X-ray image of the blood vessels to confirm the diagnosis.

Treatment for Stenosis

Treatment for stenosis involves minimally invasive procedures performed by an interventional radiologist. The most common technique is angioplasty, where a small balloon catheter is guided to the narrowed segment and inflated to physically widen the vessel and restore adequate flow. If the vessel narrows again soon after angioplasty or if the initial procedure is unsuccessful, a wire mesh tube called a stent may be permanently placed to support the vessel wall and keep the pathway open.

Treatment for Thrombosis

For a fistula that has acutely clotted (thrombosed), the urgent treatment is a thrombectomy, which is the removal of the clot. This can be achieved surgically or through endovascular techniques, such as using specialized devices to break up or suck out the thrombus. Following clot removal, an angioplasty is typically performed to correct the underlying stenosis that led to the clotting event. If these endovascular methods are not feasible, or if the damage is extensive, a vascular surgeon may need to perform revision surgery to repair the narrowed segment or even bypass the damaged area. When the fistula cannot be immediately salvaged, a temporary central venous catheter must be placed in a large vein, usually in the neck or chest, to ensure the patient can receive their scheduled dialysis treatment while a definitive plan for permanent access is developed.