What Do Lactation Cookies Actually Do?

Lactation cookies are baked goods marketed to nursing parents as a dietary aid to help increase their breast milk supply. They are specially formulated with common food ingredients traditionally believed to possess galactagogue properties, meaning they promote lactation. These treats provide a convenient way for breastfeeding individuals to consume specific substances thought to support milk production. While they resemble typical oatmeal cookies, their unique composition serves a distinct nutritional and functional purpose.

Specific Ingredients That Support Lactation

Lactation cookies typically incorporate three primary food-based galactagogues: brewer’s yeast, oats, and flaxseed. Brewer’s yeast, a byproduct of the beer-making process, is included for its rich nutritional profile, particularly B vitamins and iron. These nutrients are important for energy metabolism and combating fatigue, a common challenge for new parents.

Oats, often rolled or old-fashioned, are valued for their high concentration of the soluble fiber known as beta-glucan. Oats also supply complex carbohydrates that offer sustained energy, necessary to meet the increased caloric demands of milk production. Flaxseed, usually ground into a meal, contributes essential omega-3 fatty acids beneficial for overall maternal health. Flaxseed also provides lignans, compounds that possess weak estrogen-like qualities.

These ingredients are incorporated into the cookie format to make them palatable and easy to consume as a snack. Although other herbs like fenugreek are sometimes added, these three core ingredients form the consistent foundation of most recipes.

How These Ingredients Are Believed to Work

The proposed mechanisms by which these ingredients might support lactation are both hormonal and nutritional. The beta-glucan found in oats is theorized to play a direct role by potentially stimulating the release of prolactin, the primary hormone responsible for milk synthesis. Studies on pituitary cells indicate that beta-glucan may induce prolactin secretion, suggesting a possible biological pathway for its traditional use.

The nutritional components, such as B vitamins and iron from brewer’s yeast, support the mother’s overall physiological state. Breastfeeding significantly increases a parent’s energy needs, and deficiencies in these nutrients can contribute to fatigue, which may indirectly hinder milk supply. By providing concentrated sources, the cookies help maintain energy for lactation.

The act of eating a food item designed to help milk supply can also create a psychological comfort or placebo effect. This proactive step may reduce anxiety surrounding milk supply, which is often a factor in lactation success. Additionally, the extra calories and the requirement to consume the cookie with a beverage encourage better hydration and increased caloric intake.

Current Scientific View on Effectiveness

Despite strong anecdotal support and traditional use, the current medical consensus is that robust scientific evidence for lactation cookies is limited. Large-scale, randomized controlled trials specifically testing the efficacy of the cookies are sparse. A recent trial published in The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition found no evidence that consuming commercially available lactation cookies significantly affected human milk production rates.

The study compared objective milk production rates and perceived insufficient milk scores between a group consuming lactation cookies and a control group eating conventional cookies over a month. Researchers observed no significant difference in the amount of milk produced between the two groups. This suggests the cookies may not act as a reliable medical intervention for increasing supply.

Medical professionals generally view lactation cookies as a source of healthy, energy-dense nutrients rather than a guaranteed milk booster. The benefit may stem primarily from the extra calories and improved nutritional status of the parent, rather than a direct galactagogue effect. Consumers are advised to be cautious of products that promote health benefits without specific clinical backing.