What Did the First Prehistoric Fish Look Like?

The diversity of fish today, ranging from microscopic gobies to massive whale sharks, is a testament to millions of years of evolution. These aquatic vertebrates inhabit nearly every water body on Earth, showcasing an incredible array of forms and functions. Yet, understanding this present-day variety begins with a journey deep into the past, to unravel the mystery of what the earliest fish-like creatures truly looked like. Their ancient forms laid the groundwork for all vertebrates.

The Dawn of Vertebrates

The initial emergence of fish-like vertebrates represents a significant evolutionary milestone, tracing back to the Cambrian explosion, around 530 million years ago. During this period, the first chordates, animals possessing a notochord—a flexible rod providing skeletal support—began to appear. While not “fish” in the modern sense, these early creatures established the fundamental body plan that would eventually lead to all vertebrates.

The fossil record indicates a diversification of these early vertebrates into heavily armored forms during the Ordovician period, approximately 485 to 444 million years ago. These were the earliest known vertebrates with a backbone. These ancient jawless forms, often referred to as agnathans, were primarily filter feeders, drawing sustenance from the seabed.

Anatomy of Early Fish

The earliest fish-like creatures were notably different from the fish we recognize today, primarily lacking jaws. These jawless vertebrates, like the ostracoderms, fed by filtering small particles or detritus from the water. Their mouths were typically small and ventrally located, without the ability to bite or chew.

A defining characteristic of many early fish was their protective dermal armor. This heavy exoskeleton, composed of bony plates or scales, covered their head and often parts of their body, likely providing defense against predators like eurypterids, or “sea scorpions.” The term “ostracoderm” itself means “shell-skinned,” reflecting this prominent feature.

These ancient creatures generally had a small, elongated, and often flattened body shape, resembling primitive lampreys or tadpoles. Most were less than 30 centimeters long. Their fins were typically primitive, with paired fins often absent or only rudimentary. They possessed a caudal (tail) fin and sometimes dorsal or ventral fin folds, which provided propulsion and some stability. Simple eyes and a lateral line system, a sensory organ for detecting water movements, were also present, allowing them to navigate their aquatic environments.

Unearthing Ancient Evidence

Scientists have reconstructed the appearance of early fish by meticulously studying fossil evidence, a process fraught with challenges due to the extreme age and often fragmentary nature of these remains. The preservation of such ancient and delicate structures, particularly soft tissues, is rare. Many discoveries consist of incomplete impressions or isolated bony fragments, requiring careful interpretation and comparative anatomy.

Key insights have emerged from significant fossil sites, such as the Chengjiang biota in China, which has yielded exceptionally preserved specimens. Discoveries like Haikouichthys and Myllokunmingia, dating back to the early Cambrian period (around 518 million years ago), have provided some of the earliest evidence of vertebrate-like features. Haikouichthys, measuring about 2.5 cm, possessed an elongated body with a dorsal, ventral, and caudal fin, along with indications of a notochord, rudimentary vertebrae, and eyes. Myllokunmingia was similarly small, around 2.8 cm, and showed evidence of a cartilaginous skull and vertebral elements, representing a transitional form between early chordates and true vertebrates. These finds offer a window into the morphology of our aquatic ancestors.

From Primitive to Diverse

The evolutionary journey from these early, jawless armored forms to the vast diversity of fish today involved several significant innovations. One of the most impactful developments was the emergence of jaws, which allowed for a broader range of feeding strategies beyond filter-feeding, enabling predation and the exploitation of new food sources. This innovation appeared in the late Ordovician and early Silurian periods, approximately 450 to 419 million years ago, with groups like placoderms being among the first jawed fish.

The development of paired fins, including pectoral and pelvic fins, also marked a substantial evolutionary advancement. These fins provided improved maneuverability and control, enhancing swimming efficiency. Coupled with jaws, paired fins allowed early jawed fish to become more active and diverse predators, contributing to their evolutionary success and the decline of many jawless forms during the Devonian period, often referred to as the “Age of Fishes.” These innovations paved the way for the evolution of cartilaginous fish, like sharks, and bony fish, leading to the diverse aquatic life that populates our oceans and freshwater systems today.