What Determines the Color of Hydrangeas?

Hydrangeas are beloved garden shrubs, instantly recognizable by their massive, globe-shaped or flat-topped flower clusters. These popular plants exhibit a striking range of colors, which can shift dramatically from vibrant blue to deep pink or purple on the same bush. The ability of certain hydrangeas to change color has long fascinated gardeners, suggesting the process is not random but rather controlled by specific environmental conditions. This color variation is not genetically programmed but is a dynamic process influenced by the soil and a particular chemical element. Understanding this underlying mechanism allows gardeners to precisely control the spectrum of color displayed in their landscape.

The Key Element: Aluminum

The substance directly responsible for creating the blue hue in a hydrangea is the aluminum ion (\(\text{Al}^{3+}\)). The color of the sepals is initially determined by a water-soluble pigment called anthocyanin, which naturally produces a pink or reddish color when present alone.

The transformation to blue occurs when aluminum ions are absorbed and transported to the flower sepals. Once inside, the aluminum binds with the anthocyanin pigment, altering its molecular structure. This chemical complex shifts the color from pink to deep blue, requiring the flower to accumulate a sufficient concentration of aluminum ions.

How Soil pH Controls Color Change

The availability of aluminum for the plant to absorb is governed by the soil’s acidity or alkalinity, measured using the pH scale. Acidic soil (pH below 7.0) is necessary to make the naturally occurring aluminum soluble for uptake.

When the soil is highly acidic (pH 5.0 to 5.5), aluminum is freely dissolved and easily taken up by the roots, resulting in deep blue flowers. Conversely, in alkaline soil (pH 6.5 or higher), aluminum ions bind with other compounds, making them insoluble and unavailable. This lack of aluminum allows the anthocyanin pigment to express its natural pink or red color.

Practical Methods for Adjusting Flower Color

Gardeners can manipulate the soil environment to achieve a desired color, though the process requires patience. To encourage blue flowers, the goal is to lower the soil pH and increase the supply of soluble aluminum, typically by applying aluminum sulfate or elemental sulfur.

To promote pink blooms, the soil pH must be raised to make any available aluminum insoluble. This is achieved by incorporating garden lime, such as dolomitic or hydrated lime, into the soil. Amendments should be applied in the fall or early spring, well before the flowering season.

Varieties That Maintain a Fixed Color

The color-shifting phenomenon is primarily limited to Hydrangea macrophylla (Bigleaf Hydrangea) and Hydrangea serrata (Mountain Hydrangea) cultivars that naturally produce the necessary anthocyanin. Other popular species do not participate in this color change regardless of soil chemistry. Hydrangea paniculata (Panicle Hydrangea) and Hydrangea arborescens (Smooth Hydrangea) maintain their predetermined color, usually opening white and aging to shades of pink or red.

Pure white-flowering varieties of H. macrophylla cannot be altered either, as they genetically lack the anthocyanin pigment necessary to complex with aluminum. Without this pigment, the flowers will remain white because there is no chemical reaction to produce the blue color.