What Causes an Abnormal Pap Smear?

A Pap smear, or Pap test, is a routine screening procedure designed to detect changes in the cells of the cervix, the lower, narrow end of the uterus. During the test, a small sample of cells is collected and sent to a laboratory for microscopic examination. The purpose is to identify precancerous changes, known medically as dysplasia, before they develop into cervical cancer. An “abnormal” result means the collected cells appeared unusual or atypical to the pathologist. This indicates the detection of cellular changes, not a diagnosis of cancer itself.

The Primary Culprit: Human Papillomavirus

The single most frequent cause behind atypical cervical cells is a persistent infection with the Human Papillomavirus (HPV). HPV is a widespread, sexually transmitted infection; the majority of sexually active individuals will contract at least one strain in their lifetime. The immune system naturally clears most HPV infections within one to two years, meaning the resulting cell changes are temporary and resolve without intervention.

The concern arises when the body fails to clear specific high-risk strains of the virus, such as types 16 and 18. These persistent infections can disrupt the normal growth cycle of cervical cells, leading to dysplasia, where the cells look and behave abnormally. The Pap test detects these morphological changes, which are the earliest signs of potential progression toward cancer.

HPV strains are categorized into low-risk types, generally associated with genital warts, and high-risk types, which cause cellular changes on the cervix. Nearly all cases of cervical cancer are linked to a persistent infection with a high-risk HPV type. Therefore, testing for the presence of high-risk HPV DNA is often performed simultaneously with an abnormal Pap result to determine the underlying cause and level of risk.

The severity of the cellular abnormality detected on the Pap smear directly correlates with the potential for long-term harm. A mild abnormality is highly likely to be a transient infection that will clear on its own, especially in younger individuals. Conversely, a high-grade abnormality suggests the HPV infection has been persistent long enough to cause significant changes to the cervical cells, necessitating closer monitoring and treatment.

Other Non-Infectious and Environmental Factors

While HPV is the most common cause of significant precancerous changes, other factors can lead to an abnormal Pap smear result that is temporary or benign. Inflammation of the cervix, known as cervicitis, can cause cervical cells to appear altered or reactive under the microscope. This inflammation is often the result of common, treatable conditions not related to HPV or cancer.

A variety of vaginal and cervical infections can also mimic the cellular appearance of mild dysplasia, leading to an atypical reading. These infections include bacterial vaginosis, yeast infections, and trichomoniasis, which cause temporary changes in the cell structure. Once the underlying infection is treated, the cell changes usually resolve, and a repeat Pap test returns to normal.

Hormonal fluctuations due to pregnancy or menopause can also influence the appearance of cervical cells. For example, low estrogen levels after menopause can lead to atrophic vaginitis, where the cells appear thin and inflamed, resulting in an abnormal reading. Technical issues during sample collection, such as inadequate cell quantity or the presence of blood, can sometimes lead to an unsatisfactory or uninterpretable result, requiring a repeat test.

Understanding the Results: Grading Abnormalities

The severity of the cellular changes detected on the Pap smear is classified using standardized terminology, which helps guide the next steps in patient care. The most common finding is Atypical Squamous Cells of Undetermined Significance (ASCUS), meaning the cells look slightly abnormal but the pathologist cannot definitively determine the cause or significance. ASCUS is often linked to mild, temporary inflammation or a transient HPV infection.

A more specific finding is a Low-grade Squamous Intraepithelial Lesion (LSIL), which indicates mild dysplasia (previously Cervical Intraepithelial Neoplasia Grade 1 or CIN 1). These changes are common and are directly caused by HPV infection, though they have a high probability of regressing spontaneously as the immune system clears the virus. LSIL reflects cell abnormalities that affect the superficial layers of the cervix.

A High-grade Squamous Intraepithelial Lesion (HSIL), corresponding to CIN 2 or CIN 3, represents a more significant finding. HSIL indicates moderate to severe dysplasia, meaning the abnormal cells affect a deeper proportion of the cervical lining. Although not cancer, HSIL carries a higher risk of developing into cancer if left unmonitored or untreated.

Another category is Atypical Squamous Cells, cannot exclude HSIL (ASC-H), used when the cells are atypical enough to raise suspicion for a high-grade lesion, but the changes are not definitive. The terminology used in this grading system determines the urgency and type of follow-up required.

Next Steps After an Abnormal Result

The recommended management plan following an abnormal Pap smear is directly tied to the severity of the abnormality and the patient’s HPV status. For a mild result, such as ASCUS or LSIL, especially in a younger person, the initial approach is often watchful waiting. This involves repeating the Pap test or performing an HPV co-test in six to twelve months to see if the body has naturally cleared the infection and the cellular changes have resolved.

If the abnormal cells persist, or if the initial result indicates a higher-grade abnormality like HSIL or ASC-H, a procedure called a colposcopy is recommended. During a colposcopy, the physician uses a magnifying instrument to closely examine the surface of the cervix. A mild vinegar solution is applied to highlight any areas of abnormal cells.

If abnormal areas are identified during the colposcopy, a small tissue sample (biopsy) is taken for further analysis to confirm the grade of dysplasia. The goal of this preventative follow-up is to identify and remove any persistent high-grade precancerous lesions. Since progression to cervical cancer is generally slow, often taking several years, this systematic plan is highly effective.