What Can Be Mistaken for a Hemorrhoid?

Hemorrhoids, often referred to as piles, are swollen veins located in the anus or lower rectum. While commonly experienced, their symptoms can overlap with various other anorectal conditions, leading to confusion and potential self-misdiagnosis. Understanding the distinct characteristics of these other conditions is important for seeking appropriate medical evaluation and care.

Anal Fissures

Anal fissures are small tears or cuts in the delicate lining of the anal canal. These tears typically cause sharp, severe pain that occurs during and after bowel movements, sometimes lingering for several hours. Bright red blood may also be noticed on toilet paper or on the surface of the stool. Fissures often result from trauma to the anal lining, such as passing hard or large stools, or from chronic diarrhea. The pain from a fissure is usually described as tearing or burning, distinct from the discomfort or itching often associated with hemorrhoids.

Perianal Hematomas

A perianal hematoma is a collection of clotted blood that forms under the skin near the anus when a small blood vessel ruptures. Individuals often experience a sudden onset of severe pain, accompanied by a firm, tender lump near the anus that might appear blue or purple. While a perianal hematoma can resemble a thrombosed external hemorrhoid due to its appearance and the presence of a painful lump, it is fundamentally different. The intense, sudden pain and discoloration are key indicators.

Anal Abscesses and Fistulas

An anal abscess is a painful collection of pus caused by an infection near the anus. Symptoms include persistent, throbbing pain, localized swelling, redness, and warmth. Systemic signs of infection, such as fever and chills, can also occur.

If an anal abscess does not heal completely or is left untreated, it can sometimes develop into an anal fistula. An anal fistula is an abnormal tunnel connecting the anal canal to the skin around the anus. Symptoms of a fistula can include chronic drainage of pus or fluid, skin irritation, and recurrent pain or swelling. These conditions are infections and structural abnormalities, differentiating them from the vascular swelling of hemorrhoids.

Other Conditions with Similar Symptoms

Anal skin tags are small, painless flaps of excess skin around the anus, often remaining after a healed hemorrhoid or other irritation. Unlike hemorrhoids, skin tags typically do not cause pain or bleeding. Rectal prolapse occurs when part of the rectum protrudes through the anal opening, which some might mistake for a large hemorrhoid. Anal polyps are growths that can develop inside the rectum or anus; some can bleed, mimicking hemorrhoid bleeding.

Sexually transmitted infections (STIs), such as anal warts caused by HPV or herpes, can lead to lumps, sores, or itching in the anal region. Anal cancer can also cause symptoms like persistent bleeding, pain, or a new lump near the anus. Any persistent or unusual anal symptoms warrant medical evaluation.

When to Consult a Doctor

Consult a healthcare professional if you experience persistent or worsening pain in the anal area. Significant or continuous rectal bleeding, especially if dark red or accompanied by lightheadedness, requires prompt medical attention. Any new or growing lump near the anus should be evaluated.

Changes in bowel habits, such as unexplained constipation or diarrhea, or alterations in stool consistency or appearance, also warrant medical advice. The presence of fever, chills, or pus discharge needs professional assessment. If anal symptoms impact your daily life or do not improve with conservative self-care within a few days, medical evaluation is essential for diagnosis and treatment.