What Are the Major Pros and Cons of Dams?

A dam is a large structure built across a river or stream to hold back water, forming a reservoir. This engineering feat, dating back to ancient civilizations, has profoundly shaped human societies. Over millennia, dam construction evolved, becoming a widespread global practice, with tens of thousands of large dams now in operation. These structures have complex impacts on human populations and natural environments.

Meeting Societal Needs

Dams serve a multitude of human needs by providing a controlled and reliable water supply. Reservoirs created by dams store water for drinking, municipal use, and various industrial processes, ensuring availability even during dry periods. This stored water is also channeled for extensive irrigation systems, supporting agricultural productivity across arid and semi-arid regions. Approximately 10% of American cropland relies on water stored behind dams for irrigation.

Beyond water provision, dams are instrumental in generating hydroelectric power, a renewable energy source. This process involves channeling water from the reservoir through turbines, which then activate generators to produce electricity. Hydropower accounted for about 7% of U.S. electricity generation and nearly 37% of U.S. renewable electricity generation in 2022. Hydroelectric dams offer a flexible power source, capable of rapidly adjusting electricity output to meet varying demand.

Dams play a significant role in flood control by regulating river flow. They impound excess water during heavy rainfall or snowmelt, releasing it gradually downstream to prevent destructive flooding. This controlled release helps mitigate damage to communities and infrastructure located in floodplains. Furthermore, dams can improve river navigation by increasing water depth, allowing for easier passage of barges and ships in certain waterways.

Environmental Transformations

Dam construction profoundly alters natural river ecosystems, leading to significant environmental changes. The impoundment of water behind dams creates reservoirs that inundate vast land areas, destroying terrestrial habitats such as forests and wetlands. Downstream, dams disrupt the natural flow patterns of rivers, which can lead to altered sediment transport and changes in the riverbed. Rivers deprived of their sediment load below dams often erode their channels and banks, affecting aquatic habitats and potentially lowering groundwater tables.

Dams pose a substantial barrier to aquatic species, particularly those that undertake migrations for spawning or feeding. Fish migration routes are blocked, interrupting life cycles and leading to population declines or even extinction for species like salmon and steelhead. Even with fish passage structures, their effectiveness can vary depending on the species and the number of dams encountered. These structures can also alter water quality, affecting temperature, dissolved oxygen levels, and nutrient concentrations.

Reservoirs can also contribute to greenhouse gas emissions. As organic matter submerged by the reservoir decomposes, it can produce methane, a potent greenhouse gas. Methane emissions from reservoirs accounted for approximately 5.2% of anthropogenic methane emissions in 2020. These emissions can occur through various pathways, including bubbling, diffusion, and degassing when water passes through turbines.

Human and Financial Costs

The construction of dams often results in considerable human and financial costs. Large-scale dam projects frequently necessitate the displacement of communities living in areas designated for reservoir creation. Millions of people worldwide have been relocated due to dam projects, often facing significant social upheaval and loss of traditional livelihoods. Displaced populations may experience poorer housing, reduced access to education, and fragmented social networks.

Dam projects also require substantial financial investments for their construction, ongoing maintenance, and potential decommissioning. While offering benefits, the economic viability of some projects has been questioned due to high costs and construction delays.

Safety is another concern associated with dams, as catastrophic failure can lead to devastating downstream consequences. Though designed to be robust, dams can fail due to extreme weather events or structural issues, posing risks to human lives and property. Additionally, changes in river ecosystems caused by dams can affect the livelihoods of communities dependent on fishing or agriculture, further impacting their economic stability.