What Are the Disadvantages of Having a Pacemaker?

A pacemaker is a small, battery-powered device implanted to help regulate the heart’s rhythm by delivering electrical impulses. While pacemakers offer life-altering benefits, their implantation and long-term presence come with potential disadvantages.

Risks During Implantation and Initial Recovery

The surgical procedure to implant a pacemaker carries potential complications. Patients may experience infection at the surgical site, bruising, or swelling around the incision. Infection can sometimes necessitate antibiotic treatment or device removal.

More serious, less frequent complications can arise during lead insertion. There is a small risk of pneumothorax, or a collapsed lung, occurring in about 1% to 3.7% of procedures. Damage to blood vessels or nerves is also possible, as is cardiac perforation, where a lead might puncture the heart wall, though this is rare (approximately 0.1% to 0.8%).

Following implantation, a common early challenge is lead displacement, where the wires shift out of position. This can happen in 1% to 5.2% of cases, often within the first six weeks, and may require a follow-up procedure to reposition the leads.

Device-Specific Challenges and Malfunctions

Living with a pacemaker can involve long-term device-specific challenges. A primary consideration is battery depletion, which necessitates a replacement procedure typically every 5 to 15 years. The entire device usually requires surgical replacement.

Pacemaker leads can also malfunction over time due to issues like fracture or insulation breaks, impairing the device’s ability to deliver impulses or sense heart activity. Such lead failures or late lead displacement often require surgical revision or replacement of the affected leads. These interventions introduce additional procedural risks and recovery periods.

Another concern is electromagnetic interference (EMI), where strong magnetic or electrical fields can temporarily disrupt pacemaker operation. Caution is advised around certain medical equipment like older MRI machines, industrial machinery, or powerful household appliances. Temporary symptoms from EMI can include lightheadedness, dizziness, or palpitations.

Some individuals may experience “pacemaker syndrome,” a condition where the heart’s pacing is not optimally synchronized with its natural rhythm. This can lead to symptoms such as fatigue, dizziness, chest discomfort, shortness of breath, confusion, or lightheadedness. This syndrome can significantly impact a patient’s quality of life until device settings are adjusted.

Ongoing Lifestyle and Medical Considerations

Living with a pacemaker involves continuous adjustments and medical oversight. Immediately following surgery, patients are typically advised to restrict strenuous activities, heavy lifting (over 10 pounds), and movements that raise the arm above the shoulder on the implant side for about four to six weeks. Some long-term limitations, such as avoiding contact sports that could impact the device, might be suggested.

Regular medical follow-ups are necessary to ensure the pacemaker functions correctly, monitor battery status, and check lead integrity. These checks are typically scheduled every three to six months. These frequent appointments become a permanent part of the patient’s healthcare routine.

Medical imaging can also present challenges. Older devices may remain incompatible with MRI technology. This can sometimes limit diagnostic options or require alternative imaging methods.

Beyond the physical aspects, living with a permanent medical device can have a psychological impact. Some individuals report feelings of anxiety, depression, or concerns about body image. Adapting to the device and associated lifestyle changes can be a significant emotional process.