What Are Open and Closed Systems in Science?

The study of science requires defining a specific area of interest to observe and measure change. This defined area is known as a system, representing the portion of the universe under examination. Everything outside this designated area is referred to as the surroundings, which can interact with the system. The system and the surroundings are separated by a boundary, which may be a physical barrier or an invisible, conceptual line. Scientists classify systems based on how this boundary permits the movement of matter and energy.

Open Systems and Their Boundaries

An open system has a boundary that allows for the free exchange of both matter and energy with its surroundings. Matter refers to anything with mass, while energy is exchanged as heat or work. This system is the most common arrangement found in nature and laboratory settings. The boundary is permeable, meaning the material contents and thermal state constantly fluctuate based on external influence.

A simple example is a pot of water boiling on a stove without a lid. As the water is heated, thermal energy transfers from the stove into the water and is released as steam and heat into the air. The escaping steam represents the loss of matter across the boundary. Living organisms, such as a human body, are also open systems because they continuously take in matter like food and oxygen, and release waste. Simultaneously, they exchange energy with the environment through heat loss and intake.

Closed Systems and Energy Exchange

A closed system has a boundary that permits the exchange of energy but strictly prevents the exchange of matter. The system’s mass remains constant because the physical barrier is impermeable to material transfer. Energy, typically as heat or work, can easily pass through the boundary. This structure allows scientists to study energy changes within a fixed quantity of material.

Consider a chemical reaction inside a tightly sealed, non-insulated glass flask. The total mass of the reactants and products inside the flask will not change, as substances cannot escape the container. If the reaction generates heat, that thermal energy passes through the glass walls into the surrounding air. A pressure cooker with a closed lid is another illustration, confining the steam and water mass while allowing heat transfer from the burner inside.

Defining Isolated Systems and Real-World Examples

An isolated system is the most restrictive classification, as its boundary prevents the exchange of both matter and energy with the surroundings. This theoretical arrangement is completely self-contained, meaning its total mass and total energy remain constant. The perfect realization of an isolated system is nearly impossible because every boundary allows for some minute energy transfer over time.

The most practical approximation of an isolated system is a well-insulated, sealed container, such as a high-quality vacuum flask or thermos. A hot liquid inside the thermos is prevented from losing matter because the container is sealed. Its insulated walls significantly slow down the transfer of thermal energy, allowing the system to function as isolated for a practical duration.

The planet Earth provides a unique comparative example. Earth is often modeled as a closed system concerning matter, as the material entering or leaving the atmosphere is negligible compared to the planet’s total mass. However, the Earth is an open system with respect to energy because it constantly absorbs solar radiation and radiates thermal energy back into space. This energy exchange drives the planet’s weather patterns and life processes.

In biological terms, while an individual organism is an open system, the entire global ecosystem, or biosphere, is nearly a closed system for matter. Elements like carbon, nitrogen, and water are continuously cycled within the Earth’s boundaries. These classifications provide the necessary framework for applying the laws of thermodynamics and predicting system behavior across chemistry, physics, and environmental science.