The Problem With White Sage from San Carlos

White sage (Salvia apiana) is a fragrant evergreen shrub native to the southwestern United States and northwestern Mexico. It grows primarily in the coastal sage scrub habitat of Southern California and Baja California, extending into the western edges of the Mojave and Sonoran deserts. This plant, recognized by its silvery-white leaves and clusters of white flowers, is deeply rooted in the ecological landscape of these regions.

The Cultural Significance of White Sage

White sage holds profound cultural and spiritual importance for numerous Indigenous peoples, particularly those in Southern California and northern Baja, where it naturally occurs. It is considered a sacred plant, often referred to as “sacred sage” or “bee sage,” and is integral to traditional ceremonies and practices. For many Native American tribes, white sage is not merely a commodity but a revered tool woven into their spiritual and cultural identity.

Traditional uses of white sage include purification rituals, healing practices, and ceremonies to cleanse spaces, objects, or individuals. The smoke from burning white sage is believed to clear negative energy, promote balance, and foster healing. It is also used in prayers and gatherings to honor the Earth, its elements, and ancestors. This plant’s role extends to medicinal applications, with historical uses for various ailments.

Ethical Sourcing and Conservation Challenges

The increasing popularity of white sage, particularly outside Indigenous communities, has led to significant issues of overharvesting, threatening its wild populations and disrupting ecosystems. Commercialization often results in illegal and unsustainable harvesting practices, with poachers collecting hundreds of pounds of the herb at a time from public and private lands. This widespread demand depletes natural supplies, making it difficult for Indigenous communities to access their traditional medicine.

Cultural appropriation is a serious concern when non-Indigenous individuals use or profit from white sage without understanding or respecting its sacred context. Poachers often harvest plants disrespectfully, ripping entire plants from the ground or cutting off large branches, which prevents the plants from regenerating. This contrasts sharply with Indigenous knowledge, which advocates for taking only a few leaves at a time to ensure the plant’s survival. The commercial trade, largely fueled by a market unaware of these practices, undermines traditional stewardship and the plant’s long-term health.

Responsible Practices and Sustainable Alternatives

To engage with white sage respectfully and sustainably, individuals can adopt several responsible practices. One approach is to purchase white sage only from Indigenous-owned businesses that cultivate it or have explicit permission for sustainable harvesting. This ensures that the plant is sourced ethically and supports communities whose traditions are intrinsically linked to white sage. Avoiding wild-harvested white sage, especially if the origin is unclear, helps to reduce demand for unsustainably collected plants.

Cultivating white sage at home offers a sustainable and ethical alternative to purchasing wild-harvested material. Salvia apiana thrives in full sun and requires well-draining, sandy soil, mimicking its native arid conditions. It is a drought-tolerant plant once established, preferring minimal watering and typically needs no fertilizer due to its adaptation to nutrient-poor soils.

For those seeking cleansing or aromatic purposes without the cultural and conservation concerns associated with white sage, several alternative plants are available. Garden sage (Salvia officinalis), rosemary, lavender, cedar, mugwort, and sweetgrass are common options. Cedar is known for attracting positive energy, while lavender is often chosen for its calming properties. These plants offer diverse aromatic profiles and spiritual associations, providing respectful choices for personal practices.