Should I Remove a Toenail That’s Falling Off?

A partially detached toenail can be both painful and alarming. This separation from the nail bed, medically known as onycholysis, occurs when the nail plate lifts away from the skin underneath, often starting at the tip or sides. Understanding the correct steps to take immediately can prevent complications and support the regrowth process. The goal is to protect the exposed tissue and manage the situation safely until a new, healthy nail grows in its place, which can take up to 18 months for a toenail.

The Immediate Decision: To Pull or Not to Pull

The definitive guidance is to avoid forcibly removing a partially attached toenail yourself. Manually tearing the nail away causes severe pain, excessive bleeding, and significant trauma to the underlying nail bed. This exposed skin is highly sensitive and covered in tiny blood vessels, making it vulnerable to further injury.

Pulling the nail off also increases the risk of damaging the nail matrix, which is the tissue beneath the cuticle responsible for producing the nail plate. Injury to the matrix can result in permanent deformity, causing the new nail to grow back thickened, misshapen, or ingrown. If the partially detached section is catching on socks or shoes, carefully trim only the loose part using clean nail clippers or scissors. Leave any portion still firmly connected to the nail bed completely alone.

The detached portion of the nail plate cannot reattach to the nail bed once separated. Therefore, the immediate focus should be on protecting the exposed tissue until the nail naturally grows out and the remaining detached piece falls off. Trying to remove the remaining attached section introduces a higher risk of infection because maintaining a sterile environment is nearly impossible at home.

Safe Home Care for the Exposed Nail Bed

Once the loose portion of the nail has been trimmed or the nail has completely come off, the exposed nail bed requires meticulous care to prevent secondary infection. Start by gently washing the toe with warm water and mild soap to remove any debris or contaminants. Avoid scrubbing or soaking the area for prolonged periods, especially in the first 24 to 48 hours, as excessive moisture can slow healing.

After cleaning, the area must be dried thoroughly. Apply a thin layer of antibiotic ointment or petroleum jelly to the nail bed. This application helps keep the tissue moist, which supports the healing process, and provides a barrier against bacteria. The exposed area should then be covered with a non-stick sterile bandage or an adhesive dressing.

The bandage must be changed regularly, especially if it becomes wet or dirty, to ensure the wound remains dry and clean beneath the dressing. Until the nail bed is firm or the new nail has provided sufficient protection, avoid tight-fitting or closed-toe shoes that place pressure on the toe. Opting for open-toed footwear or wearing loose shoes will help prevent further trauma to the sensitive underlying tissue.

Identifying Causes and Knowing When to See a Doctor

The separation of a toenail is often triggered by several common factors, with trauma being the most frequent cause. This trauma can range from an acute injury, such as stubbing the toe, to repetitive microtrauma caused by ill-fitting shoes. Fungal infections, known as onychomycosis, are another widespread cause, where the fungus invades the nail bed, leading to thickening, discoloration, and eventual separation.

Other underlying conditions can also cause onycholysis, including skin diseases like psoriasis or systemic issues such as thyroid disease. Identifying the root cause is necessary because treatment must address that specific issue to ensure proper regrowth of the new nail. For instance, a fungal cause requires antifungal medication, while a skin condition may need topical treatments.

Immediate medical attention is necessary if you notice signs of an infection developing in the exposed nail bed.

When to Seek Medical Attention

  • Increasing redness, swelling, or warmth.
  • Throbbing pain or the presence of pus or foul odor.
  • The detachment was caused by a crush injury.
  • You have pre-existing conditions like diabetes or poor circulation.

People with pre-existing conditions like diabetes or poor circulation should consult a doctor immediately, regardless of the severity, as they are at a much higher risk for serious complications from foot injuries. A healthcare professional should also be consulted if the entire nail is removed, as they can assess for damage to the nail matrix.