Should I Go to the ER for Chest Pain That Comes and Goes?

Chest pain, whether continuous or intermittent, requires serious consideration due to its potential association with life-threatening cardiac events. The decision to seek emergency care should be governed by a rapid assessment of specific symptom characteristics and accompanying signs. While many causes of chest discomfort are non-cardiac, medical professionals must rule out serious underlying conditions, such as acute coronary syndrome.

Immediate Red Flags That Mandate Emergency Services

Any chest discomfort that feels like heavy pressure, squeezing, or crushing in the center of the chest requires an immediate call to 911. This presentation, often described as an “elephant on the chest,” suggests reduced blood flow to the heart muscle (ischemia). This type of pain frequently lasts longer than a few minutes or returns, making intermittency unreliable as a sign of lower risk.

A cardiac event should also be suspected if the discomfort radiates to the left arm, jaw, neck, back, or upper abdomen. Severe pain with a tearing or ripping sensation moving into the back can signal aortic dissection. Do not attempt to drive yourself to the hospital if these symptoms are present, as rapid intervention by EMS personnel can be lifesaving.

Accompanying symptoms include shortness of breath, which may occur even without chest discomfort. Autonomic responses, such as a cold sweat, nausea, or lightheadedness, indicate a serious event requiring immediate emergency care. If the discomfort is accompanied by dizziness or a feeling of impending doom, activate EMS without delay.

Analyzing the Characteristics of Intermittent Pain

Analyzing intermittent chest pain requires assessing the pain’s specific characteristics to gauge potential risk. Pain clearly related to physical exertion and consistently relieved by rest suggests stable angina, caused by narrowed coronary arteries. This discomfort typically manifests as a dull, heavy feeling lasting several minutes, and warrants prompt medical follow-up.

Conversely, sharp, stabbing pain that lasts only a few seconds is less characteristic of a cardiac origin. Discomfort that can be precisely pinpointed or changes noticeably with body positions or deep breaths often points toward a non-cardiac source. Fleeting sharp pain is unlikely to represent ischemia.

High-risk factors make any intermittent chest pain a greater concern, even if symptoms appear mild. Individuals with a history of heart disease, advanced age, tobacco use, diabetes, or high blood pressure carry a higher risk for acute coronary syndrome. For these populations, a lower threshold for emergency evaluation is prudent, as cardiac symptoms can present atypically.

Pain that is getting progressively worse, occurring more frequently, or happening with less exertion is categorized as unstable angina. This change in pattern indicates an urgent need for medical evaluation. If the intermittent pain is accompanied by palpitations or unexplained fatigue, it should be treated with increased suspicion.

Common Non-Emergency Sources of Chest Discomfort

The chest cavity contains numerous structures that can cause discomfort, frequently mimicking cardiac symptoms, though the heart remains the priority in evaluation. Gastroesophageal Reflux Disease (GERD) is the most common non-cardiac cause, where stomach acid backwashes into the esophagus, leading to heartburn. This burning pain is often felt behind the breastbone and can be perceived as pressure, making it difficult to distinguish from heart pain.

GERD discomfort is typically worse after large meals, consuming trigger foods, or lying down soon after eating. Unlike true angina, this discomfort may be relieved by antacids or acid-blocking medications, and it does not improve with rest alone.

Musculoskeletal causes, such as a muscle strain or inflammation of the cartilage connecting the ribs (costochondritis), are another frequent source of intermittent chest pain. This discomfort is often sharp, localized, and a physician can reproduce the pain by applying pressure directly to the affected spot. The pain may also worsen with specific movements or actions like deep breathing or coughing.

Panic attacks and severe anxiety can generate chest tightness that feels indistinguishable from a cardiac event. During a panic attack, the body releases stress hormones causing physical symptoms like a racing heart, rapid breathing, and chest pressure. This pain is often accompanied by dread, but the underlying cause is a nervous system response rather than coronary artery blockage.

The Emergency Room Evaluation Process

An ER visit for chest pain begins with triage, where a registered nurse assesses symptom severity and determines treatment urgency. Patients with active chest pain or high-risk features are prioritized. The first diagnostic test, a 12-lead Electrocardiogram (ECG), is typically performed within 10 minutes of arrival to measure the heart’s electrical activity and provide clues about ongoing damage or lack of blood flow.

Following the ECG, blood tests measure cardiac biomarkers, notably Troponin, a protein released when the heart muscle is injured. A single negative Troponin test upon arrival is insufficient to rule out a heart attack, as levels take several hours to rise. Therefore, serial blood samples are taken at initial presentation and again one to three hours later to look for a significant change in the Troponin level.

A Chest X-ray may also be performed to look for non-cardiac causes, such as a collapsed lung (pneumothorax), pneumonia, or aortic dissection. If initial tests are non-diagnostic but cardiac suspicion remains low, the patient is often placed in an observation unit for several hours. This allows the medical team to monitor for pain recurrence and complete the serial cardiac enzyme testing protocol.

“Ruling out” a cardiac event requires a combination of normal initial and serial ECGs, negative Troponin tests, and absence of recurrent symptoms for safe discharge. Low-risk patients may be discharged with instructions for timely outpatient follow-up with a cardiologist for further non-invasive testing, such as a stress test. This systematic process ensures life-threatening cardiac conditions are not missed.