Is Freediving Bad for You? The Risks and Safety Protocols

Freediving is a mode of underwater exploration that relies entirely on a diver’s ability to hold their breath without specialized breathing apparatus, such as scuba gear. This practice, often called apnea diving, allows for an unencumbered experience of the underwater environment. While freediving is celebrated for its meditative qualities, holding one’s breath underwater introduces inherent and serious risks. These risks, however, can be significantly managed through formal training and adherence to strict safety protocols.

Understanding Hypoxia and Blackout Risks

The single greatest danger in freediving is the sudden loss of consciousness, known as a blackout, caused by severe oxygen deprivation, or hypoxia. Blackouts occur when the partial pressure of oxygen in the blood drops below the level required to sustain brain function. This loss of consciousness is instantaneous and occurs without warning, often leading to drowning if the diver is not immediately rescued.

The most common form of this risk is “Shallow Water Blackout,” which typically happens as a diver ascends, usually within the final few meters of the surface. While the diver is at depth, high ambient pressure keeps the partial pressure of oxygen high enough to diffuse into the blood, masking oxygen consumption. As the diver rises, the ambient pressure rapidly decreases, causing the partial pressure of oxygen in the lungs to drop quickly to a level that can no longer support consciousness.

A less severe, but equally concerning, sign of oxygen deprivation is Loss of Motor Control (LMC), often referred to as “samba.” LMC manifests as a loss of coordination, shaking, or convulsive movements upon reaching the surface. This state indicates the brain is severely hypoxic, and the diver is moments away from a full blackout. LMC signals that the diver has pushed their breath-hold far beyond a safe limit and requires immediate rescue intervention.

Injuries Caused by Pressure Changes

Freediving also exposes the body to barotrauma, injuries resulting from pressure differences between the body’s air-filled spaces and the surrounding water. According to Boyle’s Law, increasing water pressure causes the volume of air within these spaces to decrease as a diver descends. If a diver cannot equalize this pressure, the surrounding tissue will be forced to compensate, leading to injury.

The most frequently encountered barotraumas involve the ears and sinuses, where failure to introduce air into the middle ear or sinus cavities causes a painful “squeeze.” If the pressure imbalance is not quickly corrected, it can lead to eardrum rupture, bleeding, or chronic sinus issues. Mask squeeze is another form of barotrauma occurring when the air space inside the diving mask is not exhaled into, causing negative pressure that can rupture capillaries around the eyes.

A more serious, though less common, injury is lung squeeze, or pulmonary barotrauma, which typically occurs at greater depths. Lung squeeze happens when the air volume in the lungs is compressed beyond the residual volume—the minimum air remaining after a maximal exhalation. This extreme compression can damage lung tissue and rupture capillaries, potentially causing a diver to cough up blood or fluid upon surfacing. Proper training in equalization techniques and chest flexibility is required to mitigate these mechanical injuries.

Essential Safety Protocols and Training

Freediving is managed as a relatively safe sport only because of strict adherence to formalized safety protocols, which mitigate inherent physiological risks. The single most important rule is the necessity of the buddy system; a freediver must never dive alone. The buddy’s role is to monitor the diver from the surface and, for deeper dives, meet them at a predetermined depth during the ascent.

A trained buddy is the only defense against a blackout, which is most likely to occur in the final moments of the dive. If a blackout or LMC occurs, the buddy is responsible for quickly bringing the diver to the surface, protecting their airway from water inhalation, and initiating rescue procedures. This immediate intervention prevents a hypoxic event from becoming a drowning accident.

Formal, certified training is a fundamental safety requirement, teaching divers the correct techniques to manage their body’s response to breath-holding and pressure. Crucially, training emphasizes avoiding voluntary hyperventilation before a dive. Hyperventilation lowers the carbon dioxide level in the blood, which is the body’s primary trigger for the urge to breathe. Suppressing this urge removes the natural warning signal that oxygen levels are getting dangerously low.

Upon reaching the surface, a diver must immediately perform recovery breaths, sometimes called “hook breathing.” This involves a sharp inhalation followed by a brief hold against a closed glottis, which helps rapidly restore oxygen partial pressure in the lungs and prevent a surface blackout. These protocols, including the buddy system and recovery breaths, must be practiced until they are ingrained, making the sport a managed risk activity.

Examining Long-Term Health Effects

The question of long-term health consequences from freediving, particularly for recreational practitioners, remains an area of ongoing research. Freediving triggers the mammalian dive reflex, an involuntary response that includes bradycardia (a significant slowing of the heart rate) and peripheral vasoconstriction, which redirects blood to the heart and brain. Repeated exposure to these physiological changes has led researchers to investigate potential chronic impacts.

Studies on elite freedivers have shown cardiac adaptations, such as slightly enlarged heart chambers, but these findings remain within normal physiological ranges for highly trained athletes. Some divers exhibit transient, mild cardiac arrhythmias during breath-holds. However, there is currently no strong evidence to suggest that safe, recreational freediving leads to significant negative long-term neurological or cardiac damage. For the average, cautious freediver, the risks are acutely managed by strict safety protocols, with no clear chronic health issues identified.