Is Biofilm Good or Bad? The Harmful & Beneficial Roles

A biofilm is a structured community of microorganisms, such as bacteria, encased in a self-produced matrix and attached to a surface. These microbial communities are widespread, found in diverse environments from natural settings to human bodies and industrial systems. Biofilms play both detrimental roles in health and industry, and beneficial roles in environmental processes and biotechnology. This article explores the varied impacts of biofilms.

Understanding Biofilms

Biofilms are complex assemblages of microbial cells that are irreversibly associated with a surface and enclosed within an extracellular polymeric substance (EPS) matrix. This matrix, often referred to as “slime,” is primarily composed of polysaccharides, proteins, lipids, and DNA. The EPS matrix provides structural support and protection for the microorganisms within the biofilm.

The formation of a biofilm typically occurs in distinct stages. It begins with the initial, reversible attachment of free-floating (planktonic) microorganisms to a surface. If not dislodged, these cells then undergo irreversible attachment, anchoring more firmly to the surface. Subsequently, the microorganisms multiply and produce the EPS, leading to the formation of microcolonies and the maturation of the biofilm into a three-dimensional structure. Finally, cells can disperse from the mature biofilm to colonize new surfaces, initiating new cycles of formation.

This communal lifestyle offers significant advantages to the microorganisms. Within the protective EPS matrix, microorganisms gain enhanced resistance to external threats. Biofilm-dwelling bacteria can be significantly more tolerant to antibiotics, disinfectants, and host immune responses compared to their free-floating counterparts. The matrix impedes antibiotic penetration, and the altered physiological state of cells within the biofilm contributes to this increased tolerance.

Harmful Biofilms

Biofilms pose substantial challenges in healthcare and industry due to their resilience. In medical settings, biofilms are a significant cause of chronic infections. They are frequently implicated in infections on medical implants, such as catheters and prosthetic joints, where they can lead to difficult-to-treat conditions. Up to 65-80% of hospital-acquired infections are attributed to biofilms.

Biofilms contribute to the persistence of chronic wounds, with over 90% of chronic wounds containing biofilm compared to only 6% of acute wounds. These microbial communities in wounds can impair healing by promoting chronic inflammation and resisting antimicrobial treatments. Dental plaque, a biofilm, causes tooth decay and gum disease. In cystic fibrosis patients, Pseudomonas aeruginosa forms intractable biofilms in the lungs, leading to chronic infections highly resistant to treatment.

Beyond healthcare, harmful biofilms impact industrial and economic operations. Biofouling, the accumulation of biofilms on surfaces in aquatic environments, causes issues in water pipes and heat exchangers. This reduces efficiency, increases energy consumption, and corrodes materials. In the food processing industry, biofilms on equipment surfaces are a major source of contamination. They can harbor foodborne pathogens like Listeria monocytogenes, Salmonella, and E. coli, leading to product spoilage, reduced shelf life, and food safety risks.

Beneficial Biofilms

Biofilms also play many beneficial roles, particularly in natural environments and biotechnological applications. In ecosystems, biofilms are integral to nutrient cycling, helping to break down organic matter and make essential nutrients available for other organisms. They are involved in the cycling of carbon, nitrogen, and phosphorus in diverse habitats, including soils and aquatic systems. Biofilms convert nitrogen through processes like nitrification and denitrification, vital for ecosystem health.

Biofilms are extensively utilized in engineered systems for environmental remediation. Wastewater treatment plants commonly employ bioreactors where beneficial biofilms break down pollutants in water. These microbial communities efficiently remove organic matter and nutrients from wastewater, leading to cleaner water discharge. Biofilms can also be used for bioremediation of contaminated sites, where they help degrade hazardous substances like hydrocarbons.

Biofilms also find applications in biotechnology. Microbial fuel cells (MFCs) harness the metabolic activity of electrochemically active bacteria within biofilms to convert organic substrates into electrical energy. These “electroactive biofilms” form on electrodes and facilitate electron transfer, a promising technology for sustainable energy generation and wastewater treatment. Beneficial microbial communities in the human gut also contribute to health by aiding digestion and protecting against pathogens.

Context and Control

Whether a biofilm is beneficial or harmful depends on its specific context, including the microbial species, environment, and surface it inhabits. A biofilm is not inherently good or bad, but its location and composition dictate its impact. A biofilm aiding nutrient cycling in a river is beneficial, while the same type causing corrosion in a water pipe is detrimental. The environmental conditions, such as nutrient availability and oxygen levels, also influence biofilm characteristics and behavior.

Managing harmful biofilms involves prevention, inhibition, and eradication strategies. Preventing initial attachment is a primary approach, achieved through surface treatments or antimicrobial coatings on medical devices and industrial equipment. Once formed, controlling biofilms can involve physical removal, such as debridement in chronic wounds, or chemical treatments like disinfectants. Disrupting cell-to-cell communication signals (quorum sensing) is another strategy to make biofilms more susceptible to treatments.

Conversely, beneficial biofilms are cultivated and optimized for their specific applications. In wastewater treatment, conditions are engineered to promote the growth of desired microbial communities. Researchers select specific microbial strains to enhance the efficiency of bioremediation processes or electricity generation in microbial fuel cells. Understanding factors that promote biofilm formation and activity allows for their deliberate cultivation and utilization.