I Hit My Toe and the Nail Is Coming Off: What to Do

When a toe injury causes the nail to lift or come off, it can be an alarming experience. While it may feel serious, many cases are manageable with appropriate home care. Understanding the injury and knowing when to seek medical attention can help ensure a smooth recovery.

Understanding the Injury

When a toe sustains a hard impact, the force can damage blood vessels beneath the nail. This leads to bleeding, causing blood to collect between the nail and nail bed, forming a subungual hematoma. The accumulation of blood creates pressure, which is painful and often appears as a dark discoloration under the nail.

This pressure can cause the nail to separate from its underlying nail bed, a process called onycholysis. The injury might also involve a laceration or tear to the nail bed itself.

Immediate First Aid

First, gently clean the injured area with mild soap and water to prevent infection. If there is bleeding, apply gentle, direct pressure with a clean cloth or sterile gauze to stop it. Elevating the injured foot can also reduce bleeding and swelling.

Apply a cold compress or ice pack for no more than 20 minutes at a time to reduce swelling and discomfort. Over-the-counter pain relievers, such as ibuprofen, can also alleviate pain and inflammation. Protect the exposed nail bed or loose nail with antibiotic ointment and a non-stick bandage, changing the dressing daily or if it becomes wet.

Knowing When to Seek Medical Attention

While many toenail injuries can be managed at home, certain situations warrant immediate medical evaluation. Seek professional care for severe or increasing pain, especially if throbbing and not relieved by home care, as this could indicate significant pressure from a subungual hematoma that may need draining.

Signs of infection also warrant prompt medical attention:
Increased redness
Swelling
Warmth
Discharge (yellow, green, brown, or white)
Unpleasant odor

Medical attention is advised if the hematoma covers more than 25% to 50% of the nail, as this increases the likelihood of an underlying nail bed laceration or even a bone fracture. If the toe is bent or distorted, or if you suspect a broken bone, an X-ray may be needed. Individuals with underlying health conditions like diabetes, neuropathy, or poor circulation should consult a healthcare provider for any toenail injury, as these conditions can delay healing and increase infection risk.

Navigating the Healing Process

The healing process involves the old nail detaching and a new nail growing in its place. Toenails grow much slower than fingernails, typically taking 12 to 18 months for complete regrowth. Initial regrowth may be observed within the first few months, but a full, healthy nail can take over a year to return.

During the initial weeks after injury, a thin, protective layer may begin to form over the exposed nail bed. As the new nail starts to emerge, it might initially appear thinner or have a different texture than your original nail. Keep the exposed nail bed clean and protected with a bandage during this sensitive period, allowing the underlying skin to harden and become less sensitive. Over time, the new nail will gradually thicken and strengthen as it grows out from the nail matrix, located at the base of the nail.

Preventing Future Toe Injuries

To avoid future toe injuries, several practical measures can be taken, especially regarding footwear. Wear properly fitting shoes with adequate toe room, as tight shoes can cause repetitive pressure or trauma to the toenails. For activities like running or sports, choose shoes with cushioning and ensure they fit snugly to prevent impact-related injuries.

Regularly trim toenails straight across, rather than curving the edges, to reduce the risk of trauma and ingrown nails. Maintain awareness of your surroundings and avoid walking barefoot where objects might be dropped or toes stubbed. In hazardous environments, wear protective footwear like steel-toed boots for defense against severe impacts.