How Was Epilepsy Treated in the Past?

Epilepsy is a neurological condition characterized by recurrent, unprovoked seizures, which are sudden surges of abnormal electrical activity in the brain. Throughout history, the understanding and treatment of epilepsy have undergone significant transformations, evolving from ancient mystical beliefs to more scientifically grounded approaches.

Ancient and Mystical Approaches

In ancient civilizations, epilepsy was often viewed through supernatural and mystical explanations, attributed to divine punishment or demonic possession. Early records from Mesopotamia (around 4000 BCE) describe “falling sickness” (Sakkikumiqtu), believed caused by demons. In ancient Greece, “epilepsy” derives from words meaning “to seize” or “to attack,” reflecting the belief that gods or spirits attacked individuals, though Hippocrates later posited a natural cause.

Treatments were largely ritualistic, including exorcisms, prayers, and amulets. Trepanation, an ancient surgical procedure, involved drilling holes into the skull to release evil spirits or alleviate pressure. Rudimentary herbal remedies were also employed.

Medieval and Early Medical Theories

During the medieval and early modern eras, the understanding of epilepsy began to shift, influenced by the ancient Greek humoral theory, which posited that imbalances in the body’s four fluids—blood, yellow bile, black bile, and phlegm—caused illness. Treatments for epilepsy were thus often aimed at restoring this humoral balance. Common interventions included bloodletting, where blood was drained from the body, and purging, which involved inducing vomiting or bowel movements to expel perceived excesses of humors. Dietary regimens were also prescribed, designed to regulate internal humors.

Despite these nascent medical theories, religious practices and folk remedies continued to play a significant role in managing epilepsy. Exorcisms, prayers to saints, and the use of protective amulets remained prevalent, reflecting the enduring belief in spiritual causes. Early herbal pharmacology also saw continued use, although its application was often secondary to the broader humoral treatments. Over time, the influence of Arabic physicians like Rhazes and Avicenna, who translated and expanded upon Hippocratic texts, contributed to a gradual shift towards viewing epilepsy as a physical ailment, recognizing factors like head injuries and diet as potential influences.

The Dawn of Scientific Inquiry

The 18th and 19th centuries marked a significant turning point, as medical understanding moved away from humoral theory towards a more anatomical and physiological view of the brain. This period saw the emergence of neurology as a distinct medical field. A significant development occurred in 1857 with the introduction of potassium bromide as the first effective anti-seizure medication by Sir Charles Locock. Initially used for women with “hysterical” epilepsy, its efficacy was later broadly recognized and popularized by physicians like Sir Samuel Wilkins and Sir William Gowers.

Further progress in pharmacological treatment came in 1912 with the discovery of phenobarbital’s anti-epileptic properties. Although already in use as a sedative, its ability to suppress seizures was observed serendipitously by Alfred Hauptmann. These pharmaceutical advances offered the first truly effective means of controlling seizures. Concurrently, early attempts at surgical intervention began to emerge, building on a growing understanding of brain localization. Sir Victor Horsley, in 1886, performed craniotomies for post-traumatic epilepsy, demonstrating that specific brain lesions could be targeted to reduce seizures.

Early 20th Century Therapeutic Discoveries

The early 20th century witnessed further advancements in epilepsy treatment, particularly in the development of more targeted anti-seizure medications and refined surgical techniques. In 1938, H. Houston Merritt and Tracy Putnam discovered the anticonvulsant properties of phenytoin, also known as Dilantin, which had been synthesized in 1908. This medication marked a significant step forward due to its effectiveness in controlling seizures with fewer sedative effects compared to earlier drugs. Phenytoin quickly became a widely adopted treatment, transforming epilepsy management.

Surgical approaches also evolved considerably, notably through the important work of Wilder Penfield and Herbert Jasper in Montreal starting in 1928. They refined techniques for temporal lobe resections, particularly for drug-resistant epilepsy, by carefully mapping brain activity during surgery. This era also saw the invention and increasing use of the electroencephalogram (EEG). Hans Berger recorded the first human EEG in 1924, and by 1935, researchers like Gibbs et al. described characteristic spike-wave patterns associated with seizures, allowing for more objective diagnosis and guiding treatment decisions.