How to Know If It’s a Hemorrhoid or Something Else

Rectal discomfort is common, often prompting questions about its cause. Understanding the symptoms of various anal and rectal conditions can help guide appropriate action and provide peace of mind.

Recognizing Hemorrhoid Symptoms

Hemorrhoids are swollen blood vessels located in the rectum or around the anus. They can be categorized as either internal or external, with different symptoms.

Internal hemorrhoids develop inside the rectum and generally do not cause pain due to fewer pain-sensing nerves. However, they commonly cause painless, bright red bleeding, often noticed on toilet paper, in the toilet bowl, or streaked on stool. Sometimes, an internal hemorrhoid can prolapse, meaning it bulges outside the anus, leading to pain and irritation.

External hemorrhoids form under the skin around the anus, an area rich in pain-sensing nerves, making them painful. Symptoms include itching, irritation, pain, and swelling around the anus. A thrombosed external hemorrhoid, where a blood clot forms, causes sudden, severe pain and appears as a hard, discolored lump. While external hemorrhoids can bleed, internal hemorrhoids are a more frequent cause of bright red rectal bleeding.

Other Common Causes of Rectal Discomfort

Several other conditions can cause rectal discomfort, sometimes mimicking hemorrhoid symptoms, but they have distinct characteristics.

Anal fissures are small tears in the lining of the anal canal, often resulting from trauma such as passing hard stools. They typically cause sharp, burning pain during and after bowel movements, which can last for minutes to hours, along with bright red blood on toilet paper or in the stool. This severe, lingering pain during defecation is a key differentiator from hemorrhoids.

Anal abscesses are painful, pus-filled infections that form near the anus. Symptoms include constant, throbbing pain that worsens when sitting, a tender and warm lump near the anus, and sometimes fever or chills. An anal fistula is an abnormal tunnel that can develop from an anal abscess, leading to persistent anal pain, swelling, and discharge of pus or blood from an opening near the anus. Unlike hemorrhoids, which are swollen veins, abscesses and fistulas are infections requiring specific medical attention.

Pruritus ani, or anal itching, is a persistent irritation of the skin around the anus. While hemorrhoids can cause itching, pruritus ani can stem from various causes, including hygiene issues, skin conditions, or even minor leakage of stool. Its primary symptom is an intense urge to scratch, which can worsen skin irritation, soreness, and burning.

A perianal hematoma is a collection of blood from a ruptured vessel near the anus, presenting as a painful, dark blue or purplish lump. It can be mistaken for a thrombosed external hemorrhoid, but a perianal hematoma is a localized blood clot, not a swollen vein.

Serious Conditions with Similar Symptoms

Some more serious medical conditions can present with symptoms that overlap with those of hemorrhoids, requiring accurate diagnosis by a healthcare professional.

Colorectal cancer can cause rectal bleeding, but the blood may be darker or tarry, and may be more persistent. Other concerning symptoms include changes in bowel habits (such as new constipation or diarrhea), unexplained weight loss, persistent abdominal pain or cramping, and a feeling of incomplete bowel emptying. Unlike hemorrhoids, these symptoms may indicate advanced disease.

Inflammatory Bowel Disease (IBD), which includes Crohn’s disease and ulcerative colitis, can also cause rectal bleeding, chronic diarrhea, abdominal pain, and unexplained weight loss. These conditions involve inflammation of the digestive tract and require distinct medical management.

Diverticular disease, characterized by small pouches in the colon, can lead to rectal bleeding, especially if blood vessels near the pouches are injured. While often painless, this bleeding can be significant, and diverticulitis (inflammation of these pouches) may cause severe abdominal pain, fever, and changes in bowel habits.

Rectal prolapse occurs when part or all of the rectum protrudes through the anus, which can be mistaken for a severe hemorrhoid. While both can involve tissue protruding from the anus, rectal prolapse involves a segment of the bowel, not just swollen veins. Symptoms can include a feeling of fullness, difficulty passing stool, and sometimes fecal incontinence or mucus discharge.

When to Consult a Doctor

Seeking professional medical evaluation is important when experiencing rectal discomfort, especially with certain symptoms.

Consult a doctor for persistent rectal bleeding, especially if the blood is dark, tarry, or significant. Severe or worsening pain that interferes with daily activities or sleep also warrants medical attention.

Changes in bowel habits, such as new onset of constipation or diarrhea, or alternating patterns, should prompt a doctor’s visit. Unexplained weight loss, which is not typically associated with hemorrhoids, is another symptom to discuss with a healthcare provider. If symptoms do not improve with home remedies after a week, or if any new or concerning symptoms arise, particularly for individuals over 40-50 years old, a medical check-up is advisable.

What to Expect at Your Appointment

During a medical appointment for rectal discomfort, your doctor will typically begin by discussing your symptoms in detail and reviewing your medical history. This includes questions about the nature of your pain, bleeding, bowel habits, and any other associated symptoms. A physical examination is usually performed, which may involve a visual inspection of the anal area and a digital rectal exam to feel for any abnormalities inside the rectum.

Depending on the initial findings and your symptoms, further diagnostic tests might be recommended. Tests may include an anoscopy, which uses a short, rigid tube to view the anal canal, or a sigmoidoscopy, which examines the lower part of the colon. If more serious conditions like colorectal cancer or inflammatory bowel disease are suspected, a colonoscopy may be performed to visualize the entire colon. These examinations help determine the cause of your symptoms and guide treatment.