How Strong Is Carbide? A Look at Its Hardness and Strength

Tungsten Carbide (WC) is one of the most resilient man-made materials, renowned for its exceptional strength and durability. This compound is formed from tungsten and carbon atoms, creating a ceramic-like structure that significantly upgrades conventional metals like steel. Carbide’s strength is defined by a unique combination of extreme surface hardness and very high compressive strength. It is the material of choice for demanding applications where tools must withstand intense friction, heat, and pressure without rapidly wearing down or deforming.

Defining Carbide’s Exceptional Hardness

The primary measure of carbide’s strength is its extreme hardness—the material’s resistance to localized deformation, indentation, and scratching. Tungsten carbide typically ranks between 9 and 9.5 on the Mohs scale, placing it just below diamond. This level of surface strength is significantly greater than that of the hardest tool steels.

Scientists quantify this property using standardized tests like the Vickers and Rockwell scales. Carbide materials often score between 1,500 and 2,600 on the Vickers Hardness (HV) scale, and 88 to 94 HRA on the Rockwell scale. This impressive hardness derives from the strong covalent bonds that form between the tungsten and carbon atoms within the crystalline structure. These bonds require enormous energy to break, giving the material immense resistance to abrasion and wear.

The final hardness is highly dependent on the microstructure, particularly the grain size of the tungsten carbide particles. Grades with finer grains and lower amounts of metallic binder achieve the highest possible hardness values. This wear resistance allows carbide tools to maintain a sharp edge for much longer periods than traditional high-speed steel alternatives.

Understanding Compressive Strength and Wear Resistance

Beyond surface hardness, carbide exhibits outstanding structural strength when resisting forces that attempt to crush or compress it. Compressive strength is the capacity of a material to withstand loads that reduce its volume without fracturing. Tungsten carbide surpasses virtually all melted, cast, or forged metals and alloys.

This high rigidity is a defining characteristic, making it two to three times as stiff as steel. Compressive strength for industrial-grade cemented carbides can reach up to 5,500 megapascals (MPa), substantially higher than the limits of most steels. This allows tools to handle massive structural loads and pressures without yielding or deforming.

The material used in most applications is “cemented carbide,” a composite where hard tungsten carbide grains are held together by a metallic binder, typically cobalt. The cobalt binder (usually 6% to 12% of the composition) provides toughness, preventing the ceramic-like carbide grains from crumbling under stress. This combination results in exceptional wear resistance that holds up under high friction and elevated operating temperatures.

Essential Applications Relying on Carbide’s Durability

The unique combination of extreme hardness and high compressive strength makes carbide indispensable where other materials would quickly fail. Roughly 65% of the world’s tungsten carbide supply is dedicated to the mining and drilling industries. Carbide inserts are pressed into the tips of rock drills, excavation tools, and mining bits to break through hard rock and ore.

The material’s ability to resist deformation ensures the cutting shape of a drill bit is maintained, reducing costly downtime for tool replacement, especially in deep-mining or oil exploration. In manufacturing, carbide is the standard for industrial cutting tools like drills, end mills, and saw blades used to machine tough alloys such as stainless steel and titanium. These tools can operate at much higher speeds than steel equivalents because carbide retains its hardness even at the elevated temperatures generated by high-speed cutting.

The material is also used in high-wear components such as nozzles, industrial dies, and protective wear plates in ore processing equipment. In precision fields, such as surgery and jewelry making, carbide’s wear resistance is utilized for long-lasting instruments and scratch-resistant rings.

The Strength Trade-Off: Brittleness and Manufacturing Challenges

While carbide is extremely hard, its strength profile includes a notable limitation: brittleness, or low fracture toughness. Hardness and toughness often exist in opposition in materials science, and carbide’s ceramic nature means it is prone to cracking or chipping under sudden impact or tensile stress. Unlike ductile metals like steel, which can bend and deform before catastrophic failure, carbide tends to fail abruptly when its fracture limit is reached.

Fracture toughness is measured by a material’s ability to resist the propagation of existing cracks. For cemented carbide, this property is significantly lower than for metals, with typical values ranging between 6 and 15 MPa√m. Manufacturers manage this trade-off by adjusting the percentage of the cobalt binder, as more cobalt increases fracture toughness but slightly reduces overall hardness.

The production of carbide components, known as powder metallurgy, is complex and costly. It involves mixing fine tungsten carbide powder with a binder and then consolidating the mixture at extremely high temperatures (around 1,400°C to 1,600°C) and pressure in a process called sintering. The high energy requirements and the cost of raw materials like tungsten limit its use to applications where its superior performance justifies the higher investment.