How Painful Is a Partial Knee Replacement?

A Partial Knee Replacement (PKR), also known as unicompartmental knee arthroplasty, replaces only the damaged section of the knee joint. This surgery is an option for patients whose arthritis is confined to just one area of the knee, typically the inner compartment. The primary goal of a PKR is to relieve pain caused by localized joint damage. This article provides a realistic understanding of the pain experience associated with this procedure and the modern strategies used to manage it.

Why Partial Replacement Often Means Less Pain

The reduced pain profile of a PKR begins with its fundamental surgical approach, which is significantly less invasive than a total knee replacement (TKR). The procedure involves a smaller incision, often only 3 to 4 inches, compared to the larger cut required for a TKR. This smaller opening translates directly to less disruption of the surrounding soft tissues, including the skin, muscle, and joint capsule.

Less post-operative pain results from the preservation of healthy anatomical structures within the knee. The surgeon only resurfaces the damaged bone and cartilage in one compartment. This leaves the healthy bone, cartilage, and major stabilizing ligaments, such as the anterior and posterior cruciate ligaments (ACL and PCL), intact. Preserving these ligaments helps the knee maintain its natural biomechanics and stability, minimizing surgical trauma and subsequent inflammatory response. This minimal tissue trauma allows for faster initial recovery and less discomfort immediately following the operation.

Immediate Post-Surgical Pain Control

Managing acute pain in the first 48 to 72 hours following a PKR is a focused process. Modern protocols employ a multimodal approach, which uses a combination of medications and techniques to target pain through different pathways in the body. This strategy maximizes pain relief while minimizing the reliance on a single class of drugs, particularly opioids.

A common component of this approach is the use of regional anesthesia, such as a nerve block, administered before or during the surgery. Blocks like the adductor canal block temporarily numb the specific sensory nerves supplying the knee, providing several hours of targeted pain relief immediately after the procedure. This initial control allows the patient to mobilize sooner and begin physical therapy with less discomfort.

In addition to nerve blocks, the multimodal regimen includes non-opioid medications started both before and immediately after surgery. These typically include scheduled doses of acetaminophen and non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) like celecoxib or ibuprofen. These medications work to reduce inflammation and pain signals centrally and locally, managing the background level of discomfort. Opioids are available for breakthrough pain that exceeds the control provided by scheduled medications, but their use is reduced by the multimodal strategy.

Pain Progression During Rehabilitation

The pain experienced after discharge shifts from acute surgical pain to a more functional, exercise-related discomfort. The recovery timeline sees a significant reduction in the initial surgical site pain within the first few weeks. Patients are advised to continue a structured pain management plan, often involving scheduled non-opioid medications and ice therapy, for the first one to two weeks to manage residual swelling and soreness.

Physical therapy (PT) is a necessary part of recovery and can introduce a new type of discomfort, often described as “working pain” or muscle soreness. This soreness is a sign that the joint is regaining strength and range of motion. During weeks 2 through 6, PT sessions focus on gradually increasing the knee’s ability to bend and straighten. These stretching and strengthening exercises often cause temporary spikes in pain, which is an expected part of breaking up scar tissue and strengthening weakened muscles.

Many patients achieve a pain milestone by the one-month mark, often reducing or stopping their prescription pain medications. By three months post-surgery, most individuals have experienced a substantial reduction in both pain and swelling, with the focus shifting to regaining endurance and returning to low-impact activities. Full recovery and the final sense of pain relief can take up to six months or more, but the most intense period of discomfort is typically limited to the first month following the procedure.