Does Wine Give You a Worse Hangover?

Wine is often singled out for causing a disproportionately intense hangover compared to other alcoholic beverages. While excessive alcohol consumption is the fundamental cause, specific compounds within wine can intensify next-day symptoms. This “wine hangover” phenomenon is rooted in unique biological and chemical factors present in the beverage. The distinction lies in how wine’s non-alcohol components interact with the body’s processing of ethanol.

The Physiological Roots of a Hangover

The foundation of any alcohol-induced hangover begins with ethanol. Ethanol acts as a diuretic by suppressing vasopressin, an antidiuretic hormone that signals the kidneys to conserve water. This suppression leads to increased urination and fluid loss, contributing directly to dehydration, thirst, and the classic headache experienced the next morning.

The body’s defense against ethanol involves a two-step metabolic process in the liver. First, alcohol dehydrogenase converts ethanol into acetaldehyde, a toxic compound. Acetaldehyde is responsible for many classic hangover symptoms, including nausea, flushing, and a rapid pulse. This toxic intermediate is then quickly broken down into less harmful acetate by a second enzyme, completing the detoxification pathway.

Unique Compounds That Increase Wine Hangover Severity

Wine contains non-ethanol substances that can worsen a hangover. These compounds, known as congeners, are byproducts formed during fermentation and aging, contributing to the drink’s distinct flavor and color. Darker beverages, such as red wine, contain higher concentrations of congeners compared to lighter drinks like white wine. The presence of these extra compounds means the body must dedicate more metabolic resources to breaking them down alongside ethanol, which may prolong toxic effects.

The concentration of biogenic amines, particularly histamines, is another unique factor, especially in red varieties. Histamines are found in grape skins and produced during fermentation; red wine can contain 20 to 200 times more histamine than white wine. For individuals with histamine intolerance who lack sufficient enzymes, consuming histamine-rich wine can trigger allergy-like symptoms. These reactions include headaches, flushing, and an inflammatory response that intensifies general hangover malaise.

Sulfites are chemical preservatives used to prevent oxidation and maintain freshness. However, scientific evidence generally refutes the popular belief that sulfites directly cause hangovers. Instead, sulfites are more likely to trigger genuine allergic or asthmatic reactions in sensitive individuals. These reactions can manifest as respiratory distress or a headache often mistaken for a hangover. White wines often contain higher levels of added sulfites than red wines, complicating the assumption that sulfites are the primary reason for red wine’s reputation.

Strategies to Minimize the Effects

Managing the wine hangover involves addressing the effects of both ethanol and the wine’s specific non-alcohol components. The most direct way to mitigate dehydration is to alternate each glass of wine with a full glass of water. Consuming food before and during drinking is also important, as this slows the absorption of alcohol into the bloodstream. This gives the liver more time to process the ethanol and its toxic metabolite, acetaldehyde.

A proactive approach involves making informed choices about the type of wine consumed. Selecting white wines or lighter varieties reduces the intake of congeners, which are strongly associated with increased hangover severity. Avoiding wines high in residual sugar may also help, as high sugar content can exacerbate dehydration and blood sugar fluctuations that contribute to feeling unwell. For those who suspect histamine sensitivity, taking a non-drowsy over-the-counter antihistamine about one hour before drinking may help reduce the severity of the inflammatory headache response.