Do You Need Surgery for a Torn Bicep?

The bicep muscle, located on the front of the upper arm, plays a significant role in arm movement. Injuries to this muscle, specifically tears in its tendons, are a common concern. The decision to pursue surgical or non-surgical management depends on factors like tear severity and activity level.

Understanding Bicep Tears

The bicep brachii muscle is a two-headed muscle that runs from the shoulder to the elbow. Its primary functions involve flexing the elbow and supinating the forearm, which means turning the palm upwards. Tears can occur at two main locations: proximally at the shoulder, where two tendons connect the bicep to the scapula, or distally at the elbow, where a single tendon attaches to the radius bone. The long head tendon at the shoulder is the most common site for proximal tears.

Bicep tears are categorized as either partial, where the tendon is damaged but not completely severed, or complete, indicating the tendon has fully detached from the bone. These injuries often result from acute events like falling on an outstretched arm or lifting a heavy object. Overuse or age-related degeneration of the tendon can also contribute to tears. Common symptoms include:

  • Sudden, sharp pain
  • An audible “pop” or snapping sound
  • Bruising that may extend down the arm
  • Weakness in the shoulder or elbow
  • A noticeable bulge in the upper arm, sometimes called a “Popeye muscle,” or an indentation near the shoulder or elbow

Diagnosis involves a physical examination to assess the arm’s appearance, range of motion, and strength, often supplemented by an MRI to determine the tear’s extent.

Non-Surgical Treatment Approaches

Non-surgical management is frequently recommended for bicep tears, particularly for partial tears or those in older individuals with lower activity demands. This approach is also considered when the tear’s functional impact is minimal. Non-surgical treatment typically includes rest, avoiding aggravating activities, and applying ice to reduce swelling and pain. Over-the-counter pain relievers can help manage discomfort.

Physical therapy is important for non-surgical recovery, focusing on restoring range of motion and strengthening surrounding muscles. While non-surgical methods can alleviate symptoms and improve function, they may not fully restore the bicep’s original strength. A cosmetic deformity, such as the “Popeye muscle,” may also persist.

Surgical Repair Considerations

Surgical intervention is considered for bicep tears in specific situations, especially for complete tears. It is often recommended for younger, active individuals or athletes who require full strength and function for their occupation or sport. Distal bicep tears, which occur at the elbow, frequently necessitate surgery because non-surgical treatment can lead to a significant loss of supination strength, impacting daily activities like turning a screwdriver. Surgery may also be an option if non-surgical treatments fail to provide adequate relief or function.

The goal of surgical repair is to reattach the torn tendon to the bone, aiming to restore strength and function and often improving the cosmetic appearance of the arm. Procedures vary depending on the tear’s location; for shoulder tears, a bicep tenodesis might be performed to reanchor the tendon to the humerus. For distal tears at the elbow, the tendon is directly reattached to the radius bone, sometimes using fixation devices like screws or buttons. While generally safe, surgical risks can include:

  • Pain
  • Bleeding
  • Infection
  • Injury to nearby nerves or blood vessels
  • Re-rupture of the repaired tendon (in rare cases)

Recovery and Long-Term Outlook

The recovery process and long-term outcomes differ between non-surgical and surgical approaches. For non-surgical recovery, symptom improvement often occurs over several weeks to a few months. While many individuals can adapt, some may experience persistent mild weakness or a noticeable cosmetic change in the arm.

Surgical recovery involves distinct phases, beginning with immobilization of the arm in a sling or brace for approximately four to six weeks to protect the repair. This is followed by a gradual progression to range-of-motion exercises, then strengthening exercises under the guidance of a physical therapist. Full recovery after surgery takes between four to six months, though it can extend up to a year for complete strength restoration. In the long term, surgical repair often restores full strength and function, particularly for complete tears or distal bicep injuries, and often resolves the cosmetic deformity. Non-surgical management, while effective for symptom relief, may result in some residual weakness compared to surgical repair.