Do You Have to Break Ribs to Do CPR?

Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation (CPR) is a critical intervention that can save lives during a cardiac emergency. When someone’s heart unexpectedly stops, immediate CPR can provide a bridge to survival until professional medical help arrives. Many people express concern about the potential for causing injury, specifically rib fractures, while performing chest compressions. This apprehension often raises questions about the safety of this life-saving technique. Understanding the realities of CPR underscores its importance in urgent situations.

The Likelihood of Rib Fractures During CPR

While concern about rib fractures during CPR is understandable, these injuries are not a guaranteed or necessary part of effective resuscitation. Studies indicate that rib fractures can occur, with some systematic reviews finding them in about 55% of patients who undergo CPR for non-traumatic cardiac arrest. Other CPR-related injuries, including sternal fractures, have been documented in around 60% of patients.

The occurrence of a fracture does not necessarily signify improper technique by the rescuer. Instead, it often reflects the significant force required to effectively compress the chest and circulate blood. These injuries are a known complication of CPR, highlighting the intensity needed for successful outcomes. Despite these injuries, immediate and proper CPR remains paramount.

Anatomical Reasons for Potential Injury

The human chest wall comprises ribs, the sternum (breastbone), and flexible costal cartilages. During CPR, rescuers apply pressure directly to the sternum to compress the heart and circulate blood. Current guidelines recommend compressing the chest to a depth of at least 2 inches (5 cm) but no more than 2.4 inches (6 cm) for adults.

The force needed for this depth places considerable stress on the chest’s bony and cartilaginous structures. Older individuals, who may have more brittle bones due to age or underlying conditions, can be more susceptible to fractures. When fractures do occur, they are typically located at the front of the chest, often affecting multiple ribs.

The Overriding Goal of Chest Compressions

The primary objective of chest compressions during CPR is to artificially circulate blood and oxygen to the brain and other vital organs when the heart stops. Without immediate and effective compressions, the brain and other tissues quickly begin to suffer irreversible damage due to lack of oxygen. The heart’s ability to pump blood is temporarily replaced by the rhythmic pressing on the chest.

Minor injuries, such as rib fractures, are a small risk compared to the certainty of death without intervention. For individuals experiencing out-of-hospital cardiac arrest, the chance of survival is nearly zero unless someone takes immediate action. Nearly 90% of people who suffer out-of-hospital cardiac arrests do not survive. Therefore, CPR’s life-saving potential takes precedence over concerns about injuries.

Performing Effective CPR

High-quality chest compressions are paramount for effective CPR. For untrained bystanders, “Hands-Only” CPR is recommended, which focuses solely on chest compressions. To ensure effectiveness, rescuers should place the heel of one hand on the center of the person’s chest, on the lower half of the sternum. The other hand should be placed directly on top, with fingers interlocked or lifted off the chest.

Compressions should be delivered at a rate of 100 to 120 compressions per minute. Each compression needs to be at least 2 inches (5 cm) deep but should not exceed 2.4 inches (6 cm). It is equally important to allow for full chest recoil after each compression, meaning the chest should return to its normal position. This full recoil allows the heart to refill with blood, ensuring that each subsequent compression is as effective as possible. Adhering to these guidelines helps maximize blood flow to vital organs while minimizing the risk of avoidable injury.