Do They Remove Meniscus With Knee Replacement?

Knee replacement surgery is a procedure designed to alleviate persistent knee pain and improve mobility by replacing damaged parts of the knee joint with artificial components. The primary objective is to enhance a patient’s quality of life by reducing discomfort and enabling greater ease in daily activities.

Understanding the Meniscus

The meniscus consists of two C-shaped pieces of fibrocartilage located within the knee joint, positioned between the thigh bone (femur) and the shin bone (tibia). Each knee contains a medial meniscus on the inner side and a lateral meniscus on the outer side. These structures serve as natural shock absorbers, distributing weight evenly across the knee joint and reducing friction during movement.

Meniscus in Total Knee Replacement

In most total knee replacement (TKR) surgeries, the natural menisci are removed. This removal is necessary because damaged meniscal tissue often contributes to pain and inflammation, and its presence would interfere with the proper fit and function of the prosthetic components. The artificial implants used in TKR are designed to replace the damaged cartilage and bone surfaces, ensuring a smooth gliding surface for the joint.

Artificial components are engineered to perform the functions of the natural menisci, including shock absorption and even weight distribution. Any remaining meniscal tissue could potentially lead to complications such as pain, stiffness, or premature wear on the artificial joint. Therefore, removing the menisci allows for a complete and stable reconstruction of the joint with the prosthetic materials. This comprehensive replacement ensures that the artificial knee can effectively mimic the natural mechanics of the joint.

Meniscus in Partial Knee Replacement

Partial knee replacement (PKR) differs from total knee replacement, often preserving healthy meniscal tissue. This procedure is performed when arthritis or damage is confined to only one compartment of the knee. Only the affected portion of the knee joint is replaced with artificial components, while the healthy bone, cartilage, and menisci in the unaffected compartments are retained.

Preserving the healthy parts of the knee, including the meniscus, allows the surgeon to maintain more of the patient’s natural knee structure. This can lead to a more natural feel in the knee after surgery and potentially a quicker recovery compared to a total knee replacement. PKR is a less invasive option, as it involves replacing only one of the three compartments of the knee, making it suitable for patients whose knee damage is localized.

Surgical Considerations and Outcomes

The decision to perform a total or partial knee replacement, and consequently how the meniscus is managed, depends on several factors. Surgeons assess the extent and location of the knee damage, the patient’s overall health, and their activity level. If damage is widespread across multiple compartments, a total knee replacement is generally recommended. However, if the damage is isolated to one area, partial knee replacement might be considered, allowing for preservation of healthy tissues.

The ultimate goal of both types of knee replacement surgery is to relieve pain and restore function to the knee joint. The artificial components used in these procedures are designed to replicate the knee’s natural mechanics, providing the necessary stability, cushioning, and smooth movement that the original meniscus once offered. These advancements in prosthetic design allow patients to regain mobility and improve their quality of life post-surgery.