Do ALS Symptoms Come and Go?

Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) is a progressive neurodegenerative disease affecting the nerve cells (motor neurons) in the brain and spinal cord that control voluntary muscle movement. These motor neurons degenerate and die, causing the brain to lose the ability to initiate and control muscle movement. ALS, also known as Lou Gehrig’s disease, causes muscle weakness, stiffness, and atrophy, and is characterized by a steady, irreversible decline in function. The typical nature of ALS symptom development is progressive, which contrasts with diseases where symptoms may remit or fluctuate significantly.

The Relentless Pattern of ALS Progression

The defining feature of ALS is its relentless, irreversible, and progressive nature; symptoms do not typically come and go. The underlying process involves the continuous accumulation of damage to the motor neurons. As these cells die, the muscle fibers they control weaken and waste away, a process that does not reverse itself.

ALS progression is often linear when measured over longer periods, reflecting the ongoing loss of function. Unlike conditions such as Multiple Sclerosis, which feature relapsing-remitting phases, ALS symptoms generally only worsen over time. There is currently no known treatment that can stop or reverse this biological progression of motor neuron death.

Despite the overall pattern of continuous decline, some individuals may experience periods known as “plateaus” where the progression rate slows down for a time. These plateaus, defined as a stable functional score for six months or longer, occur in a percentage of patients. A plateau is a temporary slowing of decline, not a reversal or significant fluctuation, and the decline typically resumes afterward.

Small, brief temporary improvements in function are occasionally observed, but large, sustained recoveries are rare. These minor improvements may be attributed to the effect of symptomatic treatments or simple measurement variability rather than a change in the disease mechanism.

Common Initial Symptoms and Onset Types

ALS usually begins subtly, with initial symptoms varying greatly among individuals, but they almost always start in one area of the body before spreading. The initial presentation is categorized into two main onset types based on the location of the first affected motor neurons.

Limb Onset

Limb Onset, or spinal onset, is the most common presentation, accounting for about two-thirds of all cases. This type first affects the motor neurons controlling the arms or legs. Early signs often include weakness in the hands, leading to difficulty with fine motor tasks like buttoning a shirt. When the lower limbs are affected first, patients may notice increased stumbling, foot drop, or difficulty walking. The initial weakness may be isolated to one limb before gradually spreading to the other side and eventually the trunk.

Bulbar Onset

Bulbar Onset occurs in approximately one-third of patients and affects the bulbar muscles in the head and neck. The earliest symptoms involve the muscles used for speaking and swallowing. Common first signs include slurred speech, hoarseness, or a nasal quality to the voice (dysarthria). Difficulty chewing and swallowing (dysphagia) may also be an early indicator. Regardless of the initial site, the disease is focal at the start before progressive motor neuron loss causes symptoms to spread.

Factors That Can Influence Symptom Perception

While the underlying disease progression is continuously downward, a patient or observer may perceive that symptoms are fluctuating or “coming and going.” This perceived variability is generally due to external factors and the body’s response to the disease, rather than a change in the actual neurodegeneration.

Fatigue and Exertion

One of the primary influences is fatigue and physical exertion. Muscle weakness and stiffness often become significantly more pronounced when an individual is tired or has overexerted themselves. Conversely, symptoms may seem to improve slightly after a period of rest, creating the illusion of recovery or remission. This change in functional ability is a temporary effect of exhaustion on the compromised muscles, not a true reversal of motor neuron damage.

Environmental Factors

Environmental factors can also impact how symptoms are perceived daily. For example, some individuals report that muscle stiffness and spasticity worsen in cold weather. Changes in temperature can heighten the feeling of tightness in muscles already subject to continuous motor neuron dysfunction.

Symptomatic Treatments

The temporary effectiveness of certain treatments designed to manage symptoms can contribute to the perception of fluctuation. Medications used to alleviate secondary symptoms, such as muscle cramps or spasticity, can provide relief that might be mistakenly interpreted as the disease improving. This temporary relief is a result of pharmacological intervention, not a halt in the disease’s progression.

Day-to-Day Variability

Normal day-to-day variability in strength and endurance is often magnified in someone with ALS. Simple fluctuations in hydration, sleep quality, or minor illness can cause a noticeable difference in functional ability from one day to the next, which can be perceived as an active fluctuation of the ALS symptoms themselves.