Do All Orthopedic Doctors Do Surgery?

An orthopedic doctor is a physician who specializes in the diagnosis, treatment, prevention, and rehabilitation of disorders affecting the musculoskeletal system, which includes the bones, joints, ligaments, tendons, muscles, and nerves. While the title often brings to mind operating rooms, not all orthopedic doctors perform surgery. Their comprehensive medical training allows them to manage conditions across a full spectrum of care. Surgical intervention is often the final consideration, used only after non-surgical options have been explored, with the goal of restoring function and relieving pain using the least invasive methods possible.

The Role of Non-Operative Orthopedists

Non-operative orthopedists are physicians who focus entirely on conservative management for musculoskeletal issues. They are frequently the first provider a patient sees, acting as a gatekeeper for more invasive procedures. These doctors use their specialized knowledge to accurately diagnose complex conditions through physical examination, imaging review, and diagnostic procedures.

The care provided by these specialists is rooted in conservative treatment techniques designed to promote healing and restore mobility without an incision. This often begins with prescribing tailored physical therapy programs to strengthen supporting musculature and improve joint mechanics. They also manage conditions using various medications, including oral anti-inflammatories, muscle relaxants, and analgesics.

A significant part of non-operative care involves interventional pain management, such as targeted injections to reduce inflammation and pain directly at the source. This can include corticosteroid injections into joints or surrounding soft tissues to address acute flare-ups of arthritis or tendonitis. For conditions like knee osteoarthritis, they may administer viscosupplementation injections, commonly known as “gel shots,” which aim to supplement the lubricating fluid within the joint.

Further conservative strategies involve the application of bracing, splinting, or casting to immobilize and protect an injured area, allowing for proper tissue healing. These doctors may also utilize regenerative medicine therapies, such as Platelet-Rich Plasma (PRP) injections, to stimulate the body’s natural repair processes. Their primary objective is to successfully treat the majority of musculoskeletal issues that do not require an operation, ensuring that surgery is reserved only for necessary cases.

The Scope of Surgical Orthopedic Practice

Orthopedic specialists who perform surgery are referred to as orthopedic surgeons. They intervene when conservative treatments have proven unsuccessful or when the injury demands immediate operative repair. Surgery is recommended for conditions involving severe structural damage, such as complex fractures, complete ligament tears, or advanced joint degeneration. These situations require mechanical reconstruction or replacement to restore stability and function.

The procedures performed by surgical orthopedists cover a vast range of complexity and anatomical sites. Common areas of practice include trauma surgery for the internal fixation of broken bones using plates, screws, or rods. Joint reconstruction involves both partial and total joint replacement, most frequently for the hip and knee, to treat arthritis.

Less invasive techniques like arthroscopy are also a major part of surgical practice, where small instruments and a camera are used to repair meniscal tears, ligament damage, and cartilage defects within a joint. The decision to operate is made after a thorough diagnostic workup confirms that the structural problem will not heal or resolve adequately with non-surgical management.

How Subspecialties Influence Practice Focus

The difference in practice focus, whether operative or non-operative, is determined by additional fellowship training completed after the five-year orthopedic residency. Residency training provides a foundation in both surgical and non-surgical management across all body regions. A one-year fellowship allows a physician to concentrate on a specific area, solidifying their expertise and defining their future practice pattern.

Subspecialties like Adult Reconstruction (Joint Replacement) and Orthopedic Trauma are highly surgical, with practitioners dedicating most of their time to the operating room. In contrast, fields such as Sports Medicine have distinct tracks where a physician can pursue either a surgical or a non-operative focus. A non-operative Sports Medicine specialist manages concussions, overuse injuries, and non-surgical fractures, often working closely with athletes.

Spine specialists can also be either operative, performing fusions and discectomies, or non-operative, managing back pain through injections and physical rehabilitation. This subspecialization allows doctors to become highly proficient in a narrow set of procedures and conditions, often leading to a voluntary limitation of practice to only surgical or only non-surgical care.

Determining Which Specialist You Need

Identifying the most appropriate orthopedic specialist depends on the nature of your musculoskeletal complaint. If your issue is chronic pain, a degenerative condition, or a simple sprain that does not involve immediate, severe trauma, starting with a non-operative orthopedist is often the best approach. These practitioners are experts in diagnosis and conservative care and can begin a treatment plan immediately.

To determine a doctor’s focus, patients should review the specialist’s online profile or practice website.

  • Look for terms such as “non-operative management,” “sports medicine physician,” or a listing of procedures like “joint injections” and “PRP.”
  • Conversely, a profile that emphasizes “total joint replacement,” “arthroscopy,” or “trauma surgery” indicates a primary surgical focus.

If a non-operative specialist determines that your condition requires surgical correction, they will refer you to an appropriate surgical colleague who specializes in that specific body area. This seamless referral system ensures that patients receive the right level of care, beginning with the least invasive options and progressing to surgery only when necessary. Choosing a physician whose focus aligns with your current need ensures you receive the most targeted and effective treatment plan.