Can You Be Healthy and Have a Heart Attack?

The sudden collapse of a seemingly fit, non-smoking person challenges the common perception of heart health. A heart attack, or myocardial infarction, occurs when blood flow to a section of the heart muscle is severely reduced or blocked, causing tissue damage. This blockage is most often caused by a blood clot forming in a coronary artery. When a person with no obvious risk factors suffers this event, it reveals that the underlying causes are far more complex than simple lifestyle choices.

Why Standard Health Metrics Can Be Misleading

The routine health screens many people rely on for peace of mind often fail to assess the true stability of the arteries. Metrics like Body Mass Index (BMI), resting heart rate, and traditional lipid panels offer a general snapshot of wellness but miss subtle, internal cardiovascular dangers. A person can maintain an ideal weight and have excellent blood pressure yet still harbor unstable arterial plaque.

The danger in atherosclerosis, the hardening of the arteries, is not solely determined by the total volume of plaque accumulated. Instead, the composition and vulnerability of the plaque deposits are far more predictive of a catastrophic event. Standard tests do not quantify the difference between a stable, calcified plaque and a soft, non-calcified plaque. These soft plaques, rich in lipids and inflammatory cells, are the most prone to sudden rupture.

A stable plaque builds up slowly and causes gradual narrowing, which may lead to symptoms like chest pain during exercise. Conversely, an unstable plaque can be small and cause minimal obstruction, but its rupture triggers an immediate blood clot that completely blocks the artery. This phenomenon explains why individuals with “normal” cholesterol and open-looking arteries can suddenly experience a massive coronary event. The focus on overall cholesterol numbers and blood pressure provides a false sense of security regarding this internal, rupture-prone risk.

The Role of Hidden Inflammatory and Genetic Markers

The underlying vulnerability of arterial plaque is frequently driven by factors invisible to standard testing, particularly chronic inflammation and specific genetic predispositions. Chronic, low-grade inflammation plays a significant role in destabilizing the protective fibrous cap covering a soft plaque. Immune cells within the plaque release enzymes that degrade the collagen structure of this cap, making it thin and susceptible to rupture.

A specialized blood test, high-sensitivity C-reactive protein (hs-CRP), measures systemic inflammation and can be an independent predictor of heart attack risk. An hs-CRP level above 2.0 mg/L suggests an elevated risk, even in patients with favorable lipid profiles. This marker reflects the body’s internal inflammatory state, which drives plaque vulnerability and clot formation.

Genetics introduce another layer of risk independent of lifestyle. A genetically determined form of cholesterol called Lipoprotein(a), or Lp(a), is a powerful, yet often unmeasured, risk factor. Lp(a) is a sticky particle that promotes plaque build-up and actively interferes with the body’s ability to dissolve blood clots.

High Lp(a) levels (above 30 mg/dL) significantly increase the long-term risk of a heart attack, even in individuals with low LDL cholesterol. Lp(a) concentration is primarily determined by inherited genes, meaning diet and exercise have little effect on its level. Individuals with extremely high Lp(a) levels (exceeding 120 mg/dL) can face a double or triple risk of a coronary event compared to the general population.

Sudden Events Not Caused By Plaque Build-up

Not all heart attacks or sudden cardiac arrests are caused by plaque-related atherosclerosis. Sudden cardiac events often occur due to different mechanisms, striking the young and otherwise healthy without warning. Spontaneous Coronary Artery Dissection (SCAD) is an example, where a non-traumatic tear forms in one of the layers of the coronary artery wall.

This tear creates a flap or false channel that blocks blood flow, leading to a heart attack. SCAD is most commonly seen in women, particularly those in their 40s and 50s, and is often associated with conditions like fibromuscular dysplasia, not high cholesterol. These events are unrelated to the plaque build-up that causes typical heart attacks.

Another non-atherosclerotic cause is myocarditis, which is inflammation of the heart muscle, often triggered by a viral infection. This inflammation can weaken the heart and cause it to beat irregularly or inefficiently, mimicking a heart attack with chest pain and elevated cardiac enzymes. Myocarditis can lead to sudden heart failure or dangerous arrhythmias.

In some cases, the issue is purely electrical, involving an inherited channelopathy in a structurally normal heart. Long QT Syndrome is a genetic disorder that affects the heart’s electrical recovery phase after a beat, creating vulnerability to a fatal arrhythmia called Torsades de Pointes. This condition can cause sudden cardiac arrest, often triggered by intense exercise or emotional stress, even in a physically fit person.