Can Leukemia Be Misdiagnosed? How and Why It Happens

Leukemia refers to a group of cancers that originate in the blood-forming tissues, primarily the bone marrow. This condition involves the uncontrolled growth of abnormal blood cells, which can interfere with the production of healthy white blood cells, red blood cells, and platelets. While a leukemia diagnosis is a serious medical event, the symptoms can often be subtle and overlap with those of other, less severe conditions, making misdiagnosis a possibility. This article explores the challenges in identifying leukemia and the reasons why it might be mistaken for other illnesses.

The Complexities of Leukemia Diagnosis

Diagnosing leukemia can be challenging due to its varied presentation and the nature of its development within the body. Leukemia cells do not form solid tumors, making them less detectable through imaging tests like X-rays or CT scans, which are common for other cancers. Instead, the disease affects the blood and bone marrow, requiring specialized diagnostic approaches.

The diagnostic process usually begins with a physical examination and a review of a patient’s medical history, followed by initial blood tests. A complete blood count (CBC) is a common starting point, as it provides information about the number of white blood cells, red blood cells, and platelets. Abnormalities in these counts, such as unusually high white blood cell levels or low red blood cell and platelet counts, can suggest leukemia.

If initial blood tests indicate potential leukemia, further specialized tests are necessary for confirmation. A bone marrow aspiration and biopsy, typically from the hipbone, allows for direct examination of bone marrow cells for abnormal morphology and blast percentages. Flow cytometry analyzes the presence or absence of specific proteins on cell surfaces to identify the type of leukemia cells. Genetic testing, including cytogenetic analysis and molecular tests like FISH (fluorescence in situ hybridization) or next-generation sequencing, helps identify chromosomal changes and gene mutations that are characteristic of different leukemia subtypes. The accurate interpretation of these complex tests requires specialized expertise.

Common Conditions Mistaken for Leukemia

Leukemia’s initial symptoms often resemble those of many other common ailments, leading to potential misidentification. Conditions like aplastic anemia and myelodysplastic syndromes (MDS) frequently share overlapping symptoms with leukemia because they also involve abnormalities in blood cell production within the bone marrow. Patients with aplastic anemia, for instance, may experience fatigue, pallor, easy bruising, and frequent infections, similar to leukemia, due to insufficient production of blood cells.

Myelodysplastic syndromes (MDS), sometimes referred to as “pre-leukemia,” also present with symptoms like fatigue, shortness of breath, easy bruising, and recurrent infections, stemming from impaired blood cell development. Viral infections, such as mononucleosis, are another frequent source of confusion, as they can cause fatigue, fever, and enlarged lymph nodes, mirroring leukemia symptoms.

Other conditions that can mimic leukemia include severe infections and autoimmune diseases, which may also trigger fever, fatigue, and general malaise. These nonspecific symptoms can easily be attributed to more benign causes, delaying the consideration of a leukemia diagnosis. The similarity in symptoms necessitates a thorough diagnostic process to differentiate leukemia from these various conditions.

Factors Contributing to Diagnostic Error

Several factors contribute to the possibility of diagnostic error in leukemia. A primary reason is the non-specific nature of early leukemia symptoms, which can include fatigue, fever, weight loss, or easy bruising. These symptoms are common to many less severe illnesses, leading healthcare providers to initially consider more prevalent diagnoses like viral infections or anemia.

The rarity of some leukemia types also plays a role in misdiagnosis, as medical professionals may be less familiar with their specific presentations. Human error in interpreting complex laboratory results or pathology slides can also occur. Early abnormalities in blood counts can also be subtle or masked by other factors, such as recent transfusions or medications.

Limitations or errors in laboratory testing can also contribute to diagnostic challenges. While blood tests are often the first step, they are not always definitive. The rapid progression of some acute leukemias can also leave little time for a comprehensive diagnostic workup, especially if initial symptoms are dismissed, potentially leading to delayed treatment.

Steps to Confirm a Diagnosis

If there is uncertainty about a leukemia diagnosis, or if symptoms persist despite a previous diagnosis of another condition, specific steps can help confirm the diagnosis. Seeking a second opinion from a hematologist or oncologist, who specializes in blood disorders and cancers, can provide additional expertise and perspective.

Requesting a review of pathology slides by another expert, particularly a hematopathologist, is also a valuable step. This ensures that the microscopic analysis of blood and bone marrow samples is thoroughly re-evaluated for any missed indicators or alternative interpretations. It is also important to ensure that all relevant diagnostic tests, such as comprehensive genetic and molecular analyses, have been performed and accurately interpreted. These tests can provide detailed information about the specific type of leukemia, which is crucial for guiding treatment.

Open communication with healthcare providers is important throughout this process. Patients should feel comfortable asking questions about their diagnosis, test results, and treatment plan. Advocating for thoroughness in diagnosis and understanding the rationale behind each step can help ensure an accurate and timely diagnosis.