Can a Heart Valve Be Repaired Without Surgery?

Heart valve disease, which involves the malfunction or damage of one or more of the heart’s four valves, historically required open-heart surgery for correction. Modern medical advancements have provided an affirmative answer to the question of non-surgical repair. Today, many patients can have their damaged heart valves treated through minimally invasive, catheter-based procedures. These innovative techniques offer a viable alternative to major surgery.

Understanding Catheter-Based Intervention

The term “non-surgical” in this context refers to interventions performed using a catheter, a thin, flexible tube, which is guided through the body’s existing blood vessels to reach the heart. This approach is formally known as percutaneous, meaning “through the skin,” because it only requires a small puncture site instead of a large chest incision. The most common entry point for these procedures is the femoral artery or vein in the groin, though sometimes a small incision in the chest is used if the groin vessels are unsuitable.

This technique fundamentally differs from traditional open-heart surgery because the heart is not stopped, and the use of a heart-lung machine is typically avoided. Instead, the physician uses advanced imaging technology, such as X-ray fluoroscopy and echocardiography, to navigate the catheter and the device it carries directly to the malfunctioning valve. This less invasive method significantly reduces the physical toll on the body and is associated with a much shorter hospital stay and recovery period.

Key Minimally Invasive Repair and Replacement Procedures

Transcatheter Aortic Valve Replacement (TAVR), sometimes called TAVI, is the most common and established of these procedures, focusing on the aortic valve, which directs blood flow out of the heart’s main pumping chamber. This procedure is designed to treat aortic stenosis, a condition where the valve opening narrows and stiffens. During a TAVR procedure, a compressed, artificial tissue valve is delivered through the catheter and expanded directly within the diseased native valve, pushing the old leaflets aside. The new valve begins to function immediately, restoring proper blood flow without the need to surgically remove the damaged valve.

For issues with the mitral valve, which controls blood flow between the heart’s upper and lower left chambers, Transcatheter Edge-to-Edge Repair (TEER) is a frequently used technique. The MitraClip device is a prime example of this repair method, specifically targeting mitral regurgitation, where the valve leaks backward. The clip is delivered via a catheter inserted through a vein in the groin and is used to grasp the edges of the two mitral valve leaflets in the middle, creating a double opening. This clipping action helps the leaflets close more completely, reducing the severity of the backward blood flow.

While TAVR replaces a valve and MitraClip repairs one, transcatheter procedures are also expanding to other heart valves. The pulmonary valve, often affected in congenital heart disease, can be replaced using similar catheter-based techniques, particularly in patients who have had prior surgical repairs. Furthermore, devices for transcatheter tricuspid valve repair and replacement are actively being developed and used in clinical trials. The goal is to address specific valve dysfunction, whether stenosis (narrowing) or regurgitation (leakage), using the least invasive mechanism possible.

Who Qualifies for Non-Surgical Valve Treatment

Patient selection for non-surgical valve treatment is a detailed process determined by a multidisciplinary Heart Team, which includes cardiac surgeons and interventional cardiologists. These procedures were initially developed for patients considered high-risk for traditional open-heart surgery due to advanced age, frailty, or significant coexisting medical conditions like chronic lung or kidney disease. For these patients, the reduced trauma and faster recovery of a catheter-based procedure offer a distinct advantage.

The indications for TAVR, for instance, have broadened significantly and now often include intermediate and even low-risk patients, especially those over 70 years old. Suitability is not based only on overall health but also on the specific anatomy of the valve and surrounding structures. Factors like the size and shape of the valve annulus, calcium buildup, and the condition of the blood vessels used for catheter access are all assessed using advanced imaging.

Anatomical features can sometimes exclude a patient from a non-surgical approach, such as having a valve that is too small or too large for the available devices, or if the path to the heart is obstructed. The decision always involves weighing the long-term durability of the transcatheter device against the patient’s estimated life expectancy and quality of life improvement.