Are There Intersex Animals? The Science of Sex Variation

The natural world often presents a more intricate picture of biological sex than a simple male and female dichotomy. While many animals appear to fit neatly into one of two sexes, a closer look reveals a spectrum of variations. These variations broaden our understanding of biological diversity across numerous species.

Understanding Intersex Conditions in Animals

Intersex in animals describes biological variations where an individual possesses sex characteristics that do not align precisely with typical male or female definitions. This is not a disease but rather a natural occurrence. These characteristics can involve discrepancies in chromosomes, gonads (reproductive organs), or external anatomy. For example, an animal might be genetically male but exhibit some female secondary sex characteristics, or vice versa.

Intersex conditions can also manifest as the presence of both ovarian and testicular tissue within the same individual. This means an animal’s internal and external sex characteristics may not be uniformly male or female.

Presence of Intersex Traits Across Animal Species

Intersex traits are documented across a wide array of animal species. In mammals, intersex conditions are observed in domestic animals like pigs, cattle, dogs, goats, sheep, and horses. For instance, between 0.1% and 1.4% of pigs are estimated to be intersex. Cattle can exhibit freemartinism, where a female twin born with a male twin develops underdeveloped reproductive organs due to shared placental blood flow and exposure to male hormones. Female spotted hyenas are also notable, as they possess an elongated clitoris resembling a penis, through which they urinate, mate, and give birth.

In birds, some species, such as chickens, can have a mosaic of genetically male and female cells, or hens may develop male characteristics if their ovary is damaged. Fish frequently show intersex conditions, often characterized by the presence of both ovarian and testicular tissue within an individual. This is particularly noted in fish living downstream from wastewater treatment plants, where environmental factors can induce such changes.

Intersexuality also extends to invertebrates. Nematodes, a type of worm, commonly show intersex traits, with many functionally female individuals exhibiting male characteristics. Crustaceans, like the marine amphipod Echinogammarus marinus, have documented intersex individuals. The oldest evidence of intersexuality in crustaceans dates back 70 million years.

Factors Contributing to Intersex Development

Several factors can lead to the development of intersex traits in animals, ranging from internal biological mechanisms to external environmental influences. Genetic factors play a role, involving chromosomal abnormalities or gene mutations that disrupt normal sex determination pathways. For example, atypical chromosome combinations, such as XXY in some mammals, can lead to intersex conditions. Mutations in specific genes crucial for sex determination can also result in ambiguous or mixed sexual characteristics.

Hormonal factors are a significant contributor. Imbalances or atypical levels of sex hormones, such as androgens and estrogens, during critical developmental stages can influence sexual differentiation. Disruptions in the production or signaling of these hormones can lead to intersex conditions.

Environmental factors can also induce intersex development. Exposure to endocrine-disrupting chemicals (EDCs), found in pollutants and pesticides, can interfere with hormonal signaling. These chemicals can mimic or block natural hormones, leading to abnormal sex development, especially in aquatic animals like fish and amphibians. Additionally, in species with temperature-dependent sex determination, such as some reptiles, temperature fluctuations during egg incubation can influence the sex of the offspring and contribute to intersex traits.

Intersex Versus Hermaphroditism

The terms “intersex” and “hermaphroditism” are often confused, but they describe different biological phenomena. Hermaphroditism refers to species where individuals naturally possess both male and female reproductive organs as a normal part of their biology or life cycle. Many invertebrates, such as snails and earthworms, are natural hermaphrodites, capable of producing both sperm and eggs. Some fish species also exhibit hermaphroditism, either simultaneously possessing both active reproductive systems or sequentially changing sex during their lives.

In contrast, intersex conditions describe a variation in sexual development within a species that typically has distinct male and female sexes. Intersex individuals possess sex characteristics that do not fit neatly into typical male or female categories, representing a deviation from the usual sexual development for that species. While a hermaphrodite is naturally designed to have both reproductive functions, an intersex animal has a combination of traits atypical for its species’ standard male or female form.