Are Leg Curls Necessary for Hamstring Development?

The leg curl machine, which involves bending the knee against resistance, is a widely used exercise in lower body training. This isolated motion focuses on the muscles at the back of the thigh, leading many to question its necessity when other complex movements are available. This article examines the biomechanical function of the hamstrings to determine the role of the leg curl in achieving comprehensive development.

Hamstring Anatomy and Dual Function

The hamstring group consists of three primary muscles: the semitendinosus, the semimembranosus, and the biceps femoris. These muscles are mostly biarticular, meaning they cross and act upon two different joints—the hip and the knee. This arrangement gives the hamstrings a dual function: hip extension (moving the leg backward) and knee flexion (bending the knee). The biceps femoris has a long head that is biarticular and a short head that is uniarticular, crossing only the knee joint. Since the short head does not cross the hip, it is only involved in knee flexion.

The Limitations of Hip-Dominant Exercises

Many lifters attempt to develop their hamstrings solely through hip-dominant exercises like the Romanian Deadlift (RDL), the conventional Deadlift, or Good Mornings. These movements are excellent for training the hamstrings in a significantly lengthened position, which is a potent stimulus for muscle hypertrophy. They place a high degree of tension on the biarticular hamstring heads as the hip flexes under load. However, these hip extension movements do not fully recruit all hamstring fibers, particularly those responsible for knee flexion. When the hamstrings are stretched over the hip joint, their capacity to produce force at the knee joint is mechanically reduced. Relying only on hip-dominant movements leaves a portion of the muscle’s functional range undertrained. The uniarticular short head of the biceps femoris is minimally engaged during hip extension exercises because it does not cross the hip joint. To maximize development across the entire muscle group, including the short head, a movement emphasizing the knee flexion function is necessary.

When Isolated Knee Flexion is Essential

The leg curl, whether performed lying, seated, or standing, isolates the knee flexion function of the hamstrings. This isolation trains the hamstrings in a shortened, contracted position, providing a complementary hypertrophic stimulus compared to the lengthened position emphasized by RDLs. Research suggests that combining both lengthened (RDL) and shortened (leg curl) training positions is superior for overall muscle growth. Isolated knee flexion also plays a role in injury prevention, particularly in sports involving sprinting and rapid direction changes. Training the hamstrings to generate force in a shortened position helps improve the hamstring-to-quadriceps strength ratio. This balance is important for knee joint stability and reducing the risk of muscle strain. For individuals seeking maximal and balanced hamstring development, the leg curl is necessary. It ensures the short head of the biceps femoris receives a dedicated training stimulus and provides a unique contraction profile across all heads. Viable alternatives, such as the Nordic Hamstring Curl, can also fulfill this requirement of isolated knee flexion.